Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Petitioner Maria Isabel A.S., a citizen of Chile, entered the United States on November 3, 2022 under the Visa Waiver Program, authorized to stay until January 31, 2023. She remained beyond that date without authorization. On July 4, 2023, she filed a Form I-589 application for asylum and withholding of removal, and her asylum proceedings are ongoing. Before her detention she worked, owned a cleaning company, paid taxes, and was the primary caregiver for her five-year-old son.
She was arrested by local police in Florida on July 6, 2026, with no prior criminal history, and was transferred to ICE custody the next day. ICE later moved her to the California City Immigration Processing Center. On October 2, 2026, she filed a habeas petition and a motion for a temporary restraining order in the Eastern District of California, seeking release or, alternatively, a bond hearing. Respondents argued she was lawfully detained under 8 U.S.C. § 1187(c)(2)(E) for violating the Visa Waiver Program, and that she was subject to mandatory detention under 8 U.S.C. § 1231(a)(2) because she had a final administrative removal order that asylum-only proceedings did not affect. She argued that neither statute applied, that 8 U.S.C. § 1226(a) governed, and that her detention violated due process. She also contended her asylum application predated the July 8, 2026 removal order and prevented it from becoming final.
The Court’s Holding
Chief Judge Troy L. Nunley granted the petition and ordered immediate release. Relying on Quispe v. Chestnut and Hsiao v. ICE Field Officer, he held that § 1187(c)(2)(E) does not confer detention authority over Visa Waiver Program violators, and he found the Board of Immigration Appeals' Matter of A.W. unpersuasive. He also held that § 1231(a)(2) does not apply, because a Visa Waiver Program removal order is not final while an asylum application is pending. Riley v. Bondi and Johnson v. Guzman Chavez addressed withholding-only relief, which concerns where a person may be removed rather than whether she may be removed. Asylum, by contrast, can allow a person to remain in the country. The court therefore held that § 1226(a) governs her detention.
On due process, the court found a protected liberty interest, because she was admitted on a visa, immigration officials knew of her presence, and the government did not detain her when her status lapsed. Applying the three Mathews v. Eldridge factors, it weighed her substantial interest in freedom after more than four months in custody and separation from her family. It found a considerable risk of erroneous deprivation, since the record showed no initial custody determination or stated basis for detention. It found the government's burden from providing the statutory safeguards minimal. Detention without notice or any hearing violated procedural due process.
The court ordered the following: Respondents must release her, return her documents and possessions, and certify compliance within two court days. They are enjoined from re-detaining her while she is subject to § 1226(a) without at least seven days' notice and a pre-deprivation hearing before a neutral factfinder, with counsel allowed. At that hearing the government must show by clear and convincing evidence that its interest in protecting the public or ensuring her appearance outweighs her liberty interest and that no alternative to detention can mitigate the risk. If she becomes subject to a final and executable removal order, they must give at least ten days' written notice of intent to detain her. The TRO motion was denied as moot, and the clerk was directed to enter judgment for Petitioner and close the case.
Key Takeaways
- Section 1187(c)(2)(E) of the Visa Waiver Program statute does not itself authorize detention of noncitizens who violate the program's terms.
- In this ruling, a Visa Waiver Program removal order was not final under § 1231(a)(2) while the noncitizen's asylum application was pending, because asylum bears on whether she may be removed at all.
- A noncitizen admitted on a visa who then lived openly and sought asylum had a protected Fifth Amendment liberty interest in her continued freedom, even if she is ultimately removable.
- Over four months of detention under § 1226(a) without an initial custody determination, notice, or a hearing failed the Mathews balancing test and violated procedural due process.
- The injunction conditions any re-detention on seven days' notice and a hearing with a clear-and-convincing standard, and on ten days' written notice if a final, executable removal order issues.
Why It Matters
The decision adds to a line of Eastern District of California rulings rejecting the argument that Visa Waiver Program overstayers can be held without a bond hearing under § 1187(c)(2)(E) or § 1231(a)(2). Its reasoning on finality rests on the distinction between withholding-only relief and asylum drawn in Guzman Chavez, as applied in Hsiao.
The ruling also shows the remedy some courts are granting in these cases: release, plus a re-detention injunction with a heightened pre-deprivation hearing. This is a single district court ruling, and it addressed only this petitioner's detention.