Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Maikel Pomo Bermudez, a noncitizen detained by immigration authorities, petitioned for a writ of habeas corpus challenging his prolonged detention under Zadvydas v. Davis and the revocation of his supervision order. The court resolved the Zadvydas claim because it afforded complete relief, declining to address the supervision revocation.
Ordered removed to Cuba in November 2020, Bermudez was released on supervision when removal failed. Following subsequent criminal convictions, including a May 2025 drug arrest, ICE re-detained him in February 2026 after his release from county jail. Bermudez refused to consent to removal to Mexico and remained detained for nearly eight months while the government claimed continued authority under 8 U.S.C. § 1231(a)(6).
The Court’s Holding
The court granted the petition, holding that Bermudez satisfied his burden under Zadvydas by demonstrating detention beyond the six-month presumptive period and no significant likelihood of foreseeable removal. Removal to Cuba was unlikely given past failure and lack of renewed efforts, while removal to Mexico was not reasonably foreseeable because Mexico conditioned acceptance on Bermudez's consent, which he withheld.
Rejecting the government's argument that Bermudez's refusal to consent was an impermissible self-inflicted barrier, the court held that civil detention cannot be used to strong-arm third-country removals requiring noncitizen consent. The court ordered Bermudez released under supervision pursuant to 8 U.S.C. § 1231(a)(3), staying the order for 14 days to allow respondents to explore transferring him to local law enforcement custody.
Key Takeaways
- Detention under 8 U.S.C. § 1231(a)(6) is presumptively limited to six months, shifting the burden to the government once a detainee shows no significant likelihood of foreseeable removal.
- A detainee's refusal to consent to third-country removal does not rebut a Zadvydas showing when the receiving country's acceptance is conditioned on that consent.
- Immigration authorities may not use prolonged civil detention as coercive leverage to compel consent to third-country deportation.
- Courts may stay an order releasing a noncitizen on supervision to allow authorities to evaluate transfer to local law enforcement custody.
Why It Matters
The decision reinforces district court consensus that the government cannot convert conditional third-country removal pacts into mechanisms for indefinite civil confinement by treating a noncitizen's lack of consent as an obstruction of removal.
The ruling also underscores that criminal history cannot override the constitutional and statutory limits established in Zadvydas, though the court balanced public safety concerns by granting a temporary stay for potential transfer to local custody.