Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Plaintiff Devonte B. Harris, a state prisoner proceeding pro se, brought this 42 U.S.C. § 1983 action alleging civil rights violations while housed in the Security Housing Unit at Corcoran State Prison. Following partial leave to amend, plaintiff filed a third amended complaint against correctional officers D. Arden, A. Garcia, C. Gamboa, J. Pasillas, and D. Perez. The court screened the pleading under 28 U.S.C. § 1915A.
Plaintiff alleged that on June 14, 2019, Arden and Garcia handcuffed and escorted him under the pretext of a medical evaluation. After plaintiff referenced an earlier excessive force grievance against them, Arden slammed him to the ground, and Arden, Garcia, Gamboa, and Pasillas punched and kicked him. Plaintiff alleged Defendant Perez arrived, watched the beating for several minutes, and failed to intervene before ordering officers to lift him. Plaintiff suffered broken teeth, a jaw fracture, and spinal injuries.
Plaintiff further alleged the officers authored false reports accusing him of battery and resistance to cover up their assault. The Kings County District Attorney filed felony charges carrying potential 25-years-to-life sentences. The battery charge was later dismissed unconditionally, and the remaining charges were dismissed after plaintiff completed pretrial mental health diversion without an admission of guilt.
The Court’s Holding
The court held that plaintiff stated plausible Eighth Amendment excessive force claims against all defendants. Although plaintiff did not allege that Defendant Perez applied physical force, the court found a viable claim against Perez under a bystander failure-to-intervene theory because he watched the ongoing assault for several minutes without acting despite a realistic opportunity to intervene. The court also sustained First Amendment retaliation claims, finding allegations that the officers attacked plaintiff and filed false reports because of his protected grievance activity.
Applying Thompson v. Clark, the court held that criminal proceedings dismissed after successful completion of California pretrial mental health diversion satisfy the Fourth Amendment favorable-termination requirement without requiring affirmative proof of innocence. The court also sustained a Fourteenth Amendment deliberate fabrication of evidence claim under Devereaux v. Abbey, concluding the officers' allegedly fabricated reports proximately caused felony charges. The court ordered the action to proceed on all four claims and directed defendants to answer within 30 days.
Key Takeaways
- An officer who observes fellow officers assaulting a restrained prisoner and fails to act despite having a realistic opportunity to intervene is liable for Eighth Amendment excessive force under a failure-to-intervene theory.
- Dismissal of criminal charges following successful completion of pretrial mental health diversion satisfies the favorable termination element of a Fourth Amendment Section 1983 malicious prosecution claim under Thompson v. Clark.
- Correctional officers face Fourteenth Amendment liability for deliberate fabrication of evidence when they intentionally author false reports that proximately cause prosecutors to initiate felony charges against an inmate.
- Allegations that officers physically attacked an inmate and lodged false disciplinary charges shortly after he referenced prior excessive force grievances plausibly state a First Amendment retaliation claim.
Why It Matters
This screening order illustrates the application of Thompson v. Clark to state diversionary dispositions, confirming that dismissal through pretrial mental health diversion constitutes favorable termination for Section 1983 malicious prosecution claims without requiring affirmative proof of innocence.
The decision also demonstrates that bystander officers who observe excessive force without intervening face direct Eighth Amendment liability, even in the absence of direct physical participation or supervisory authority.