California Case Summaries

Luis Cruz Morales v. Warden — Federal Magistrate Recommends Dismissing Section 2241 Habeas Petition Challenging BOP Disciplinary Sanctions for Possessing Cell Phone Charger

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Luis Cruz Morales v. Warden
Court
U.S. District Court — Eastern District of California
Judge
Magistrate judge (name not printed in the order)
Date Decided
2026-11-17
Docket No.
1:25-cv-01749
Status
Unreported
Topics
habeas corpus, prison disciplinary proceedings, Code 108 hazardous tool, due process, some evidence standard, Bureau of Prisons

Background

Petitioner Luis Cruz Morales, a federal inmate in the custody of the Federal Bureau of Prisons at the Federal Correctional Institution in Mendota, California, filed a pro se petition for a writ of habeas corpus pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 2241 challenging a prison disciplinary sanction. The underlying disciplinary charge arose from an April 23, 2023, random search of the prison cell assigned to Cruz Morales and his cellmate. During that search, a correctional officer discovered a USB charging cable and adapter concealed inside an overhead light fixture. Disciplinary staff issued an incident report charging Cruz Morales with a violation of Bureau of Prisons Code 108 for possession of a hazardous tool. After completing an investigation, prison staff referred the charge to the Unit Discipline Committee, which subsequently referred the matter to a Disciplinary Hearing Officer based on the severity of the accused prohibited act.

On May 23, 2023, the Disciplinary Hearing Officer conducted a hearing and found Cruz Morales committed the prohibited act of possessing a hazardous tool. The hearing officer based this finding on the officer's written report, evidence photographs of the recovered black USB C-type charging cable and wall charger, the chain of custody form, and Cruz Morales's own statement during the hearing admitting that he knew the contraband was there. As a sanction, the hearing officer imposed forty-one days of disallowed good conduct time, 270 days of disciplinary segregation, the forfeiture of 283 days of non-vested good conduct time, 365 days of impoundment, and a one-year loss of commissary, email, telephone, and MP3 player privileges. Cruz Morales filed his federal habeas petition on December 5, 2025. Respondent filed a motion to dismiss on April 17, 2026, and Cruz Morales filed no reply.

The Court’s Holding

The magistrate judge recommended granting Respondent's motion to dismiss and dismissing the habeas petition for failure to state cognizable federal habeas claims. Analyzing Ground One, the magistrate judge addressed petitioner's contention that the evidence was insufficient because no cellular phone was discovered and because the charging document referenced Cell 227 rather than Cell 224. Applying the standard established in Superintendent v. Hill, the court explained that due process requires only that some evidence supports the disciplinary decision to revoke good conduct time, without requiring independent reweighing of credibility or evidence. Relying on settled case law, the court held that Code 108 discipline extends to the unauthorized possession of a cell phone charger or charging cord alone. Furthermore, the court determined that the cell number reference was a harmless clerical error, as official prison records confirmed petitioner was assigned to Cell 227 on the date of the search.

The magistrate judge similarly rejected petitioner's remaining procedural claims. Under Ground Two, petitioner asserted that the incident report was false and retaliatory. The court observed that filing an allegedly false disciplinary report does not by itself violate constitutional rights where an inmate receives procedural due process before the deprivation of liberty and where the allegations are not made in retaliation for exercising constitutional rights. Because the petition contained no facts alleging retaliation for exercising constitutional protections and Cruz Morales received the required process, Ground Two failed to state a cognizable claim. Addressing Ground Three, which challenged the denial of a staff representative at the Unit Discipline Committee hearing, the court noted that under federal regulations the committee cannot revoke good conduct credits. Because the committee cannot deprive an inmate of a protected liberty interest, Wolff procedural requirements do not apply to its proceedings.

Key Takeaways

  • Under the 'some evidence' standard, federal habeas review of prison disciplinary decisions does not permit reweighing evidence or reassessing witness credibility.
  • Sanctions under Bureau of Prisons Code 108 for possession of a hazardous tool apply to cell phone chargers and cables even without an accompanying mobile phone.
  • Clerical errors concerning cell numbers on disciplinary incident reports do not undermine evidentiary sufficiency when administrative records establish the prisoner's actual occupancy.
  • Constitutional due process protections under Wolff do not attach to preliminary Unit Discipline Committee hearings because the committee cannot revoke good conduct credits.

Why It Matters

This recommendation underscores the rigorous hurdle inmates face when challenging federal prison disciplinary proceedings under Section 2241. By confirming that charging equipment alone qualifies as a hazardous tool and that non-adjudicatory committee stages lack constitutional liberty implications, the decision reaffirms the substantial institutional deference accorded to correctional disciplinary authorities.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top