California Case Summaries

Chadwick W. Smith v. FCA US, LLC — Plaintiff’s Counsel Sanctioned $2,056.16 Under Rule 16(f) for Failing to Appear at Pretrial Settlement Conference

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Chadwick W. Smith v. FCA US, LLC
Court
U.S. District Court — Eastern District of California
Judge
Magistrate judge (name not printed in the order)
Date Decided
2026-11-17
Docket No.
1:25-cv-00036
Status
Unreported
Topics
civil procedure, Rule 16(f) sanctions, failure to appear, settlement conference, attorney fees, Local Rule 110, California State Bar reporting

Background

In this federal civil action pending in the Eastern District of California, the court initiated sanction proceedings against plaintiff's counsel, Larry Chae, for noncompliance with pretrial directives under Local Rule 110. On October 14, 2026, the court ordered Mr. Chae to show cause in person on October 29, 2026, why sanctions should not be imposed for repeated failures to comply with court orders. On October 26, 2026, Mr. Chae filed a declaration confirming that he would appear in person for both the order to show cause hearing and the scheduled settlement conference.

Despite his written representation, Mr. Chae failed to appear at the October 29, 2026 proceedings. Neither Mr. Chae nor any representative from his law firm notified the court or explained his absence before or during the hearing. The court vacated the settlement conference and directed defense counsel to submit an itemized declaration detailing the fees and expenses incurred in appearing. The court also issued a second order to show cause regarding counsel's non-appearance, continuing both matters to be heard concurrently.

Defense counsel Julie Cooper timely submitted an expense declaration, and Mr. Chae filed responsive declarations. Following a continuance granted at Mr. Chae's request, the court conducted a consolidated hearing on November 17, 2026. Mr. Chae appeared in person on behalf of the plaintiff, while defense counsel Jacky Wang appeared remotely via Zoom. The court evaluated counsel's explanations under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 16(f) and its inherent docket-management authority.

The Court’s Holding

The court discharged the initial October 14, 2026 order to show cause while sustaining the second order and imposing sanctions. On the first order, the court determined that although Mr. Chae arranged untimely coverage for his appearance at the pretrial settlement conference, an attorney from his law firm did ultimately appear, establishing sufficient good cause to discharge that order without penalty.

However, the court found neither good cause nor substantial justification to excuse Mr. Chae's failure to appear at the October 29, 2026 conference. Given the procedural record and counsel's prior confirmation that he would attend in person, the unexcused absence violated pretrial orders and warranted monetary relief under Rule 16(f)(2) and Local Rule 110. After reviewing defense counsel's itemized submission, the court approved expenses directly caused by counsel's absence: $241.09 for car rental, $210.48 for lodging, $104.59 for fuel, and $1,500.00 for four hours of travel and appearance time at $375.00 per hour.

The court ordered Mr. Chae to pay the resulting total sanction of $2,056.16 personally to Narain Maclear LLP within thirty days, explicitly forbidding him from passing the cost to his client. Because the sanction exceeded $1,000.00, the court reminded counsel of his statutory obligation under California Business and Professions Code § 6068(o)(3) to report the sanction to the State Bar of California within thirty days. Lastly, the court ordered the parties to meet and confer within thirty days to reschedule the settlement conference, which the court will consider conducting remotely upon meaningful cooperation.

Key Takeaways

  • Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 16(f)(2) directs courts to assess reasonable expenses and attorney fees against counsel who fails to appear at a pretrial conference unless substantial justification is shown.
  • Courts enforce personal liability for scheduling sanctions, strictly prohibiting counsel from shifting the financial burden of court-ordered penalties onto the client.
  • Attorneys practicing in California federal courts face independent statutory obligations under California Business and Professions Code § 6068(o)(3) to self-report judicial sanctions exceeding $1,000 to the State Bar.
  • Affirmative written assurances to attend court proceedings undermine subsequent assertions of justification if counsel fails to appear without prior notice or explanation.

Why It Matters

This decision underscores the mandatory financial remedies provided by Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 16(f) to compensate opposing parties when pretrial proceedings are disrupted by attorney non-appearance. Rather than viewing scheduling orders as flexible guidelines, federal courts exercise their authority to ensure that travel and appearance costs incurred in good faith by opposing counsel are reimbursed.

Additionally, the ruling emphasizes the intersection between federal court sanctions and state attorney discipline. By highlighting counsel's statutory duty under California Business and Professions Code § 6068(o)(3) to report sanctions exceeding $1,000, the decision illustrates how unexcused scheduling defaults can trigger formal state bar oversight and broader professional consequences.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top