Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Plaintiff Michael Lee Piccolotti sought judicial review under 42 U.S.C. § 405(g) of a final decision of the Commissioner of Social Security denying his application for disability insurance benefits under Title II of the Social Security Act. Plaintiff alleged disability beginning September 25, 2024, at age thirty-three, due to lumbar degenerative disc disease with sciatica, knee and shoulder pain, migraines, depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder. Following initial and reconsideration denials by the agency, Plaintiff requested an administrative hearing, which was conducted telephonically by an administrative law judge on November 6, 2025, with testimony from Plaintiff and a vocational expert.
On November 26, 2025, the ALJ issued an unfavorable decision applying the five-step sequential evaluation process. At step two, the ALJ determined that Plaintiff suffered from severe impairments consisting of lumbar degenerative disc disease, migraines, depression, and PTSD, but concluded at step three that none met or medically equaled a listed impairment. The ALJ then assessed Plaintiff with the residual functional capacity to perform light work with postural restrictions, simple routine tasks, and occasional contact with coworkers and the public. Relying on vocational expert testimony identifying jobs such as marker, cleaner, and small products assembler, the ALJ found at step five that Plaintiff was capable of performing work existing in significant numbers in the national economy.
Although the ALJ acknowledged that Plaintiff's underlying impairments could reasonably produce his alleged symptoms, the ALJ rejected his subjective statements concerning symptom severity as not entirely consistent with the record. After the Appeals Council denied review, the ALJ's decision became the Commissioner's final decision. The parties consented to the jurisdiction of a United States Magistrate Judge, and Plaintiff filed briefs arguing that the ALJ failed to provide specific, clear, and convincing reasons supported by substantial evidence to discount his subjective complaints.
The Court’s Holding
United States Magistrate Judge Sheila K. Oberto vacated the Commissioner's decision and remanded the case for further proceedings pursuant to sentence four of 42 U.S.C. § 405(g). The court explained that under binding Ninth Circuit precedent, because the claimant presented objective evidence of impairments that could reasonably cause the alleged symptoms and there was no showing of malingering, the ALJ could reject his subjective symptom testimony only by providing specific, clear, and convincing reasons supported by substantial evidence.
The court held that the ALJ erred by selectively relying on isolated normal exam findings—such as Plaintiff's normal motor strength, unassisted ambulation, and ability to bend at the waist during a consultative examination—while ignoring significant objective medical evidence documenting severe spinal pathology, muscle spasms, tenderness, and positive clinical tests. The court noted that this cherry-picking of medical records failed to account for documented disc desiccation, facet joint fluid, and positive straight leg raise tests that supported Plaintiff's physical complaints. Furthermore, the ALJ completely failed to explain how normal physical metrics contradicted Plaintiff's testimony regarding frequent incapacitating migraines and debilitating psychological symptoms from depression and PTSD.
The court additionally ruled that Plaintiff's daily activities did not undermine his credibility. Although the ALJ pointed to Plaintiff's self-report that he cooked, cleaned, drove, and shopped, the ALJ improperly omitted his extensive qualifying statements showing that he performed chores only with spousal assistance, at waist level, with frequent rest, and subject to severe physical pain and reminders. Because a properly credited assessment of Plaintiff's limitations could have yielded a more restrictive residual functional capacity and precluded competitive work, the error was not harmless, warranting vacatur and remand.
Key Takeaways
- An ALJ must provide specific, clear, and convincing reasons supported by substantial evidence to reject a disability claimant's subjective symptom testimony absent affirmative evidence of malingering.
- Adverse credibility findings cannot be sustained through impermissible cherry-picking of isolated normal examination findings while ignoring contemporaneous clinical evidence of spinal pathology and functional limitation.
- An adjudicator must articulate a rational connection explaining how physical examination results contradict episodic or non-exertional impairments, including migraine headaches, depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder.
- Reported activities of daily living do not undermine a claimant's credibility when the ALJ fails to consider essential qualifications showing that tasks are performed with assistance, modification, and substantial rest.
Why It Matters
This decision illustrates the rigorous enforcement in the Ninth Circuit of the clear and convincing standard for evaluating subjective pain and symptom testimony in Social Security disability appeals. The ruling reinforces that reviewing courts will reject administrative decisions that isolate normal physical exam metrics while disregarding the full context of chronic impairments and qualified daily activities.