Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Petitioner Maria Angelica Saravia Cok, a citizen of Bolivia accorded lawful permanent resident status in the United States, arrived at Miami International Airport on January 1, 2026, returning from Bolivia. Customs and Border Protection officers inspected her, searched her cellular telephone, and alleged evidence of engagement in prostitution as well as false statements on a prior naturalization application. Authorities placed Saravia Cok into custody, issued a notice to appear, and initiated removal proceedings charging her as an inadmissible arriving noncitizen under several provisions of the Immigration and Nationality Act.
In immigration court, Saravia Cok initially withdrew a custody redetermination request and filed motions to suppress evidence and terminate proceedings. Following evidentiary hearings in April 2026, an immigration judge denied both motions on June 3, 2026, finding that the Department of Homeland Security established removability as charged. On June 29, 2026, Saravia Cok filed a pro se federal habeas corpus petition under 28 U.S.C. section 2241 in the Eastern District of California, challenging her prolonged mandatory detention without an individualized bond hearing as a violation of Fifth Amendment procedural due process. On October 30, 2026, the immigration judge ordered her removed, with an administrative appeal period running through late November 2026.
The government opposed habeas relief, contending that Saravia Cok was subject to mandatory detention under 8 U.S.C. section 1225(b)(2) and section 1226(c)(1)(A). The government also maintained that she failed to exhaust administrative remedies by not seeking a custody redetermination hearing under Matter of Joseph in immigration court. Saravia Cok did not file a traverse, and the matter stood submitted on the magistrate judge's docket.
The Court’s Holding
The magistrate judge recommended granting the habeas petition and denying Saravia Cok's motion for immediate release. Addressing exhaustion, the court concluded that prudential exhaustion was not warranted because she did not dispute statutory applicability under section 1225(b) or section 1226(c), which would be addressed in a Joseph hearing, but instead raised an as-applied constitutional due process challenge to prolonged confinement that immigration judges cannot resolve.
Turning to the constitutional merits, the magistrate judge declined to adopt a rigid six-month bright-line rule and instead applied the three-factor balancing test from Mathews v. Eldridge. The court found that Saravia Cok possessed a fundamental private interest in freedom from bodily restraint, which was severely compromised by ten months of detention without an individualized hearing before a neutral decisionmaker. Against this substantial liberty interest, the court weighed the government's interest, emphasizing that the focus is not general immigration enforcement but the government's narrow interest in continuing confinement without a hearing, which entails minimal fiscal or administrative cost.
For the remedy, the magistrate judge recommended directing the respondent to provide Saravia Cok with an individualized bond hearing before an immigration judge under the standards articulated in Singh v. Holder. At that hearing, the government must justify continued detention by proving by clear and convincing evidence that she is a flight risk or danger to the community, and the immigration judge must consider her financial circumstances and alternative conditions of release.
Key Takeaways
- Prudential exhaustion does not preclude federal habeas relief when a noncitizen brings an as-applied constitutional challenge to prolonged mandatory detention rather than disputing statutory coverage under Matter of Joseph.
- Due process challenges to prolonged immigration detention in the Eastern District of California are evaluated under the flexible Mathews v. Eldridge balancing test rather than a categorical six-month bright-line rule.
- Ten months of mandatory immigration detention without any custody review before a neutral decisionmaker creates an acute risk of erroneous liberty deprivation that favors procedural relief.
- At a constitutionally mandated bond hearing, the government bears the burden of establishing flight risk or dangerousness by clear and convincing evidence to justify continued custody.
- Immigration judges conducting court-ordered bond hearings must evaluate a detainee's financial circumstances and nonmonetary release conditions if detention without bond is unnecessary.
Why It Matters
The recommendation reinforces that Supreme Court precedents in Jennings v. Rodriguez and Johnson v. Arteaga-Martinez eliminated only implied statutory six-month limits, leaving as-applied constitutional challenges under the Due Process Clause fully available to prolonged detainees. By applying Mathews v. Eldridge, the decision illustrates how extended mandatory confinement without neutral review ripens into a constitutional violation.
Furthermore, the decision confirms the ongoing vitality of Singh v. Holder's clear and convincing evidentiary standard in the Ninth Circuit, ensuring that noncitizens facing protracted mandatory detention receive robust procedural safeguards and consideration of release alternatives.