California Case Summaries

Ursula Leon Hernandez v. Henkels & McCoy, Inc. — Summary Judgment Granted to Employer on FEHA Sex Discrimination and Retaliation Claims Where Gender-Neutral Portable Restrooms Did Not Violate FEHA and Documented Performance Deficiencies Negated Pretext

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Ursula Leon Hernandez v. Henkels & McCoy, Inc.
Court
U.S. District Court — Northern District of California
Judge
Jon S. Tigar (Barack Obama, 2013)
Date Decided
2026-11-16
Docket No.
4:25-cv-02963
Status
Unreported
Topics
FEHA retaliation, sex discrimination, gender-neutral restrooms, prima facie case, legitimate nondiscriminatory reason, pretext, Rule 56(d) discovery

Background

Plaintiff Ursula Leon Hernandez, a union journeyman electrician, was dispatched through a union hiring hall to contractor Henkels & McCoy, Inc. ('H&M') as a substation technician at project sites in Tracy and San Francisco, California. At both sites, H&M provided unisex portable toilets to all workers. Leon Hernandez objected to the facilities as disgusting and asked foremen and general foreman Dave Roberts for women's restrooms, asserting that California construction standards contemplated sex-segregated facilities. Roberts declined, stating that providing separate women's restrooms would discriminate against men under company training. After her termination, H&M reviewed applicable state regulations and instructed Roberts to provide a locked women's restroom on site.

Supervisors documented performance issues regarding Leon Hernandez at both locations. At Tracy, she was cited for chronic tardiness, safety hazards, and crew friction, prompting a transfer to the Trans Bay Cable ('TBC') site. At TBC, supervisor Babi Varner reported that Leon Hernandez struggled with directions, cut a cable with a coworker contrary to orders, and violated general-contractor Siemens' rules by soliciting blueprints directly from client personnel. Roberts decided to terminate her employment based on these infractions. Although Leon Hernandez contacted human resources and a compliance hotline before discharge, H&M terminated her on April 30, 2021, recording the exit as a layoff at her union's request. Leon Hernandez sued in state court alleging FEHA sex discrimination and retaliation, and H&M removed the action to federal court.

The Court’s Holding

United States District Judge Jon S. Tigar granted summary judgment to H&M, granted Leon Hernandez's administrative motion, and denied as moot her partial summary judgment motion and discovery appeal. The court held that Leon Hernandez failed to establish a prima facie case of FEHA retaliation because complaining about unisex portable toilets was not protected activity opposing unlawful discrimination. California regulations require equal access to comparable, safe, and adequate facilities without regard to sex. Because H&M provided identical portable toilets to male and female workers, its neutral policy constituted equal treatment rather than discrimination. Objecting to shared facilities or citing industrial safety standards does not constitute protected activity where the challenged practice cannot reasonably be understood as unlawful FEHA discrimination.

The court also ruled that Leon Hernandez failed to establish a prima facie case of sex discrimination. Her documented performance record, which included chronic tardiness, safety infractions, and unauthorized communications, showed she was not performing her job satisfactorily, and she offered no evidence of satisfactory performance. Additionally, she failed to show that similarly situated male coworkers were treated more favorably. She identified no male worker with comparable performance infractions who was spared discipline, and both she and her male counterpart were equally reassigned following the wire-cutting incident.

Finally, the court held that even if a prima facie showing were made, Leon Hernandez failed to produce specific and substantial evidence that H&M's legitimate performance justifications were pretextual. Reclassifying her discharge as a layoff was a requested accommodation from her union rather than evidence of pretext, and supervisory accounts consistently confirmed her operational shortcomings. Judge Tigar also denied discovery under Rule 56(d), concluding that Leon Hernandez failed to pursue discovery diligently during the open discovery period and failed to demonstrate how the requested evidence would preclude summary judgment.

Key Takeaways

  • Complaining about across-the-board unisex portable restrooms does not constitute protected activity under FEHA because providing identical facilities to male and female employees is equal treatment rather than unlawful discrimination.
  • Opposition to workplace practices grounded solely in external industrial safety standards does not support a FEHA retaliation claim unless the employee reasonably believes the employer violated FEHA itself.
  • To establish a prima facie case of disparate treatment discrimination, a plaintiff must demonstrate satisfactory job performance and identify similarly situated employees outside the protected class treated more favorably.
  • An employer's post-termination decision to reclassify an employee's discharge from a do-not-rehire termination to a layoff at a union's request constitutes an accommodation that cannot serve as evidence of pretext.

Why It Matters

This decision clarifies the scope of protected activity under California employment law, establishing that employee complaints regarding uniform gender-neutral sanitary facilities at construction sites do not constitute opposition to unlawful discrimination under FEHA. By distinguishing industrial safety mandates from statutory non-discrimination rules, the ruling confirms that employers providing equal facility access across all workers do not violate FEHA. Furthermore, the decision affirms that post-termination accommodations granted at a union's request cannot be converted into evidence of discriminatory animus to defeat summary judgment.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top