Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Plaintiff Marlucia Fiuza, a 62-year-old flight attendant employed by United Airlines for 33 years and represented by the Association of Flight Attendants (AFA), was first terminated in June 2023 for refusing a reassigned trip. Fiuza challenged the discharge through internal appeals and an October 2023 letter to a United executive asserting age discrimination. In March 2024, United reinstated Fiuza subject to a two-year probationary period. In October 2024, Fiuza worked a West Virginia University charter flight staffed with younger attendants, where she was assigned to the cabin rear contrary to seniority and protested. Crew members and a university travel secretary subsequently complained of unprofessional behavior, which Fiuza denied while noting younger attendants committed unpenalized infractions.
United investigated and terminated Fiuza a second time on December 6, 2024. During appeals, United withheld witness statements and video evidence, and on April 25, 2025, AFA declined to arbitrate her grievance. Fiuza then sued United for age discrimination under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) and California's Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), retaliation under Title VII and FEHA, whistleblower retaliation under California Labor Code Section 1102.5, failure to prevent discrimination under FEHA, and wrongful termination. Against AFA, she claimed breach of the duty of fair representation under the Railway Labor Act (RLA) and hostile work environment under the RLA and Title VII. Both defendants moved to dismiss.
The Court’s Holding
United States District Judge Jon S. Tigar denied United's motion to dismiss Fiuza's ADEA, FEHA discrimination, FEHA retaliation, Section 1102.5 retaliation, FEHA failure-to-prevent, and wrongful termination claims. The court held that the RLA did not preempt federal claims because RLA preemption applies only to state law, and did not preempt state claims because they did not turn on an active dispute over collective bargaining terms. Fiuza plausibly stated age discrimination claims by alleging discharge based on uncorroborated complaints while younger attendants were not disciplined for comparable conduct. Furthermore, nine-month and fourteen-month intervals between protected complaints and discharge plausibly supported causation for state retaliation.
The court granted United's motion to dismiss Fiuza's Title VII retaliation and hostile work environment claims with leave to amend. Although her second termination occurred within the default 180-day filing period, as Fiuza did not initially file with an authorized state agency to trigger the 300-day window, her Title VII claims failed because Title VII covers race, color, religion, sex, and national origin, not age. Additionally, the court dismissed Fiuza's RLA hostile work environment claim against United without leave to amend because she abandoned it.
The court denied AFA's motion to dismiss the RLA breach of duty of fair representation claim, holding that it was timely brought within six months of April 25, 2025, when Fiuza learned of the refusal to arbitrate. Fiuza plausibly alleged arbitrary conduct based on AFA's refusal to arbitrate an uncorroborated discharge where United withheld supporting evidence, and the court declined to evaluate the union's unpled probationary defense at the pleading stage. However, the court dismissed the RLA hostile work environment claim against AFA as duplicative without leave to amend, and dismissed the Title VII hostile work environment claim against AFA because age is not actionable under Title VII and Fiuza failed to name AFA in her EEOC charge.
Key Takeaways
- The Railway Labor Act does not preempt independent state statutory claims unless resolving them requires interpreting disputed provisions of a collective bargaining agreement.
- Title VII substantive discrimination and retaliation claims cannot be predicated on age discrimination or opposition to age bias, which remain exclusively governed by the ADEA or state statutes.
- A union's refusal to arbitrate an employee's termination grievance may constitute an actionable arbitrary breach of the duty of fair representation where the worker plausibly alleges an absence of investigation or corroborating evidence.
- A plaintiff who fails to name a labor organization as a respondent in an underlying EEOC charge is barred from asserting Title VII claims against the union absent an applicable administrative exhaustion exception.
Why It Matters
The ruling reinforces jurisdictional and pleading boundaries in aviation employment disputes within the Ninth Circuit. By holding that RLA preemption does not displace California's statutory discrimination and whistleblower protections absent an active dispute over contract interpretation, the decision preserves judicial access for airline employees asserting independent state rights. Additionally, the decision illustrates the limits of Rule 12(b)(6) review, confirming that factual defenses regarding union arbitral discretion cannot defeat well-pleaded claims at the dismissal stage, while reiterating that Title VII cannot be used to litigate age-based grievances.