Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Monica Franklin, a California resident and first-time commercial real estate investor, bought an Ohio property in August 2017 through Marcus & Millichap as the sellers' broker. After the mattress-store tenant stopped paying rent, was evicted, and its parent guarantor entered bankruptcy, Franklin sold the property at a substantial loss and sued the broker for misrepresentation and fraudulent concealment.
The case reached a jury trial in September 2024. After Franklin rested her case-in-chief, the trial court granted Marcus & Millichap's nonsuit motion, finding no direct evidence of actual knowledge and misrepresentation, and dismissed the claims with prejudice. Judgment was entered for the broker in October 2024, and Franklin appealed on four grounds.
The Court’s Holding
The Court of Appeal held the nonsuit was proper because Franklin presented no substantial evidence that broker Dustin Javitch made a false statement, knew any statement was false, or lacked reasonable grounds for believing it. Statements that the tenant was a strong company, that its financials were stronger than another property's, and that it operated over 175 stores were supported by information from the sellers or the company website, with no contrary evidence of falsity or knowledge.
The court also found no concealment claim: evidence that other prospective purchasers received financials, that comparables were discounted for the guarantor's lower credit relative to a larger competitor, and that Franklin was told financials would go only to a lender did not show Javitch possessed undisclosed facts materially affecting the property's value. Any error applying an Ohio rather than California standard of care, excluding expert testimony on a national standard of care, or excluding an e-mail thread under Evidence Code section 352 was harmless because the evidence failed on the core elements regardless.
The court separately denied Franklin's request for judicial notice of an expert deposition transcript because the entire deposition did not appear to have been before the trial court and it was unnecessary to the appeal. It affirmed the judgment and awarded Marcus & Millichap its appellate costs.
Key Takeaways
- A seller's broker has no fiduciary duty to the buyer, and fraudulent-concealment liability requires actual knowledge of facts materially affecting value that are known or accessible only to the broker.
- Reliance on information from sellers or a company website can supply reasonable grounds for a broker's statements, defeating both intentional and negligent misrepresentation theories.
- Speculation that a broker must have known more than disclosed cannot substitute for substantial evidence of falsity, scienter, or concealment at the nonsuit stage.
- Even an assumed error in the governing standard of care or exclusion of expert testimony is harmless when the plaintiff's proof fails on the essential elements of the claims.
- Evidence Code section 352 permits exclusion of marginally probative e-mails whose inference chain would confuse the issues and consume undue trial time.
Why It Matters
This unpublished opinion reinforces the demanding proof required against a seller's agent in misrepresentation and concealment cases and illustrates how nonsuit can dispose of claims built on inferences rather than evidence of the agent's knowledge.
The court's alternative harmless-error analysis shows that choice-of-law and evidentiary disputes may be left unresolved when the plaintiff's underlying proof is independently insufficient.