California Case Summaries

Carrillo v. Kearney — Anti-SLAPP Motion Fails When Implied Covenant Claim Rests on Non-Protected Conduct as Well as Litigation

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Carrillo v. Kearney
Court
2nd District Court of Appeal
Judge
Mori; Zukin; Daum
Date Decided
2026-11-19
Docket No.
B353022
Status
Unreported / Non-Citable
Topics
anti-SLAPP, breach of implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, mixed causes of action, step one burden, deed restrictions, CC&Rs

Background

In 2002, Linda Carrillo purchased a residential property from Raymond Kearney pursuant to a grant deed containing covenants, conditions, and restrictions (CC&Rs) governing improvements and setbacks. After becoming next-door neighbors, disputes persisted over improvements Carrillo made or sought to make on her property. In August 2025, Kearney sued Carrillo for declaratory and injunctive relief and private nuisance, alleging that her backyard construction violated CC&R setback restrictions, and he obtained an ex parte temporary restraining order.

Carrillo answered and cross-complained for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, declaratory relief, and cancellation of the CC&Rs. She alleged that Kearney engaged in a long pattern of disingenuous enforcement beyond the deed terms, including lodging daily unfounded municipal complaints, demanding unilateral plan approval, harassing her, physically pushing her, and threatening litigation over bamboo plantings.

Kearney filed a special motion to strike Carrillo's implied covenant cross-claim in its entirety under Code of Civil Procedure section 425.16, arguing that the claim arose solely from his protected constitutional right to petition the court to enforce the CC&Rs. The trial court denied the anti-SLAPP motion, and Kearney appealed.

The Court’s Holding

The Second District Court of Appeal affirmed the order denying the special motion to strike. The court held that under the first step of anti-SLAPP analysis, when a defendant seeks to strike an entire cause of action without proposing a surgical excision of specific allegations under Bonni v. St. Joseph Health System, the defendant bears the burden of establishing that all acts supplying the elements of that claim constitute protected activity.

Because Carrillo's implied covenant claim was grounded in allegations of extrajudicial harassment, physical confrontation, and bad-faith interference alongside the lawsuit itself, Kearney failed to prove that the entire claim arose exclusively from protected petitioning conduct. The court rejected Kearney's attempt to exclude non-litigation allegations through an asserted statute of limitations defense at step one, confirming that substantive merits and procedural defenses are evaluated only at step two after protected activity is shown.

Key Takeaways

  • A moving defendant seeking to strike an entire cause of action under anti-SLAPP must show that all acts supplying the elements of that cause of action are protected activity.
  • If a challenged claim is mixed, the defendant must request a surgical strike in the initial motion by identifying specific allegations and establishing why each is protected, as courts will not parse pleadings sua sponte.
  • Courts evaluate whether a claim arises from protected conduct at step one without assessing substantive pleading merits or affirmative defenses such as the statute of limitations.

Why It Matters

This decision reinforces the California Supreme Court's Bonni framework rejecting the old 'gravamen' analysis for mixed claims. Moving parties must specifically parse and excise unprotected conduct rather than attempting to sweep an entire cause of action away under the banner of related litigation.

In neighbor and real property disputes involving CC&Rs, cross-claims alleging extrajudicial harassment and bad-faith enforcement cannot be struck wholesale under section 425.16 simply because the neighbor also initiated court enforcement proceedings.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top