California Case Summaries

Zayo Group, LLC v. CVIN, LLC — Court grants leave to file second amended and supplemental complaint after discovery revealed new permit and loan-covenant facts

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Zayo Group, LLC v. CVIN, LLC
Court
U.S. District Court — Northern District of California
Judge
Beth Labson Freeman (Barack Obama, 2014)
Date Decided
2026-11-20
Docket No.
5:25-cv-03483
Status
Unreported
Topics
leave to amend, Rule 16 good cause, Rule 15 factors, discovery misconduct, gross negligence, intentional interference with contract, scheduling order modification

Background

Zayo sued CVIN over fiber-optic cable replacement work that allegedly caused prolonged outages, asserting claims for breach of contract, breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, and intentional interference with contract. Zayo later amended its complaint and voluntarily dismissed the intentional interference claim. After Magistrate Judge Susan van Keulen granted two motions to compel—yielding supplemental responses on July 13, 2026, and loan-covenant disclosures in August 2026—Zayo moved for leave to file a second amended and supplemental complaint adding gross negligence, realleging intentional interference, and seeking punitive damages.

CVIN opposed, arguing Zayo lacked good cause under Rule 16, delayed unduly under Rule 15, acted in bad faith, would cause undue prejudice by expanding damages near discovery deadlines, and asserted futile claims barred by the economic loss rule. Following a November 19, 2026 hearing, the district court memorialized its oral ruling granting leave to amend.

The Court’s Holding

The court found good cause under Rule 16(b)(4) because Zayo diligently pursued discovery over eight months—engaging in two meet-and-confers and prevailing on two motions to compel—and moved to amend six days after its second motion succeeded. The court rejected CVIN's prior-knowledge defense, finding cited exhibits did not show Zayo knew CVIN had failed to apply for roughly ten required Caltrans permits before forcing Zayo off its leased routes or that CVIN misrepresented a loan-covenant completion date.

Under Rule 15(a)(2), the court found no undue delay or bad faith because Zayo moved promptly after receiving CVIN's supplemental discovery responses in July and August 2026. Realleging a voluntarily dismissed claim was permissible, and CVIN showed no undue prejudice: defending new claims is insufficient, CVIN's own discovery conduct caused the delay, and Zayo agreed to extend the schedule. The court declined to decide futility, preserving CVIN's economic loss rule defense for a motion to dismiss.

Key Takeaways

  • A party establishes good cause under Rule 16(b)(4) by diligently pursuing discovery to uncover new facts and moving promptly once those facts are disclosed.
  • A motion for leave to amend is not unduly delayed or brought in bad faith when based on information disclosed only in belated discovery responses.
  • A plaintiff may reallege a previously withdrawn claim in an amended pleading when newly discovered facts support doing so.
  • The burden of defending new claims or facing punitive damages does not constitute undue prejudice under Rule 15, especially when the opposing party contributed to the delay.
  • Futility challenges, including defenses under the economic loss rule, are generally deferred to a Rule 12(b)(6) motion to dismiss rather than resolved on a motion for leave to amend.

Why It Matters

This decision illustrates that courts will excuse missed pleading deadlines when diligent discovery practice uncovers the factual basis for new claims, and that an opposing party's discovery delays undermine its claims of undue prejudice.

The ruling also underscores the Ninth Circuit's strong policy favoring decisions on the merits under Rule 15, showing district courts often defer substantive defenses like the economic loss rule to motions to dismiss while extending case schedules.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top