Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Plaintiff Veronica S. Lee-Chapman, proceeding without counsel, filed this action on March 30, 2026. On May 29, 2026, the Court granted Plaintiff's motion to proceed in forma pauperis and directed Plaintiff to provide to the United States Marshal all information needed by the Marshal to effect service of process on Defendants TransUnion LLC and Goldman Sachs Bank USA, including all information required for proper service of summons under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4. Summons was returned unexecuted as to TransUnion LLC on August 6, 2026.
On September 29, 2026, the Court ordered Plaintiff to submit a revised USM-285 form to the Marshal to effect service on TransUnion and to file a statement of compliance by October 16, 2026. After Plaintiff failed to respond, the Court issued an order to show cause on October 27, 2026, giving her fourteen days to show why the action should not be dismissed as to TransUnion for failure to prosecute and warning that noncompliance would result in a dismissal recommendation. Plaintiff filed no response to the order to show cause.
The Court’s Holding
Applying the Ninth Circuit's Rule 41(b) factors for involuntary dismissal, the magistrate judge found that dismissal was warranted because the public interest in expeditious litigation and the Eastern District of California's heavy caseload favored moving the docket forward. Although the risk of prejudice to unserved TransUnion was minimal, stale litigation consumes court resources. Furthermore, the Court had already attempted less drastic alternatives through the service-cure order and the order to show cause, and Plaintiff's own persistent inaction outweighed the general public policy favoring disposition of cases on their merits.
The magistrate judge separately concluded that dismissal was warranted under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4(m) and the Ninth Circuit's insufficient-service standards. TransUnion was never served and had not participated in the lawsuit, while Plaintiff suffered no cognizable prejudice because her own lack of action prompted the dismissal. Consequently, the magistrate judge recommended that the action be dismissed as to Defendant TransUnion LLC only, leaving Plaintiff's claims against Goldman Sachs Bank USA unaffected.
Key Takeaways
- A magistrate judge may recommend involuntary dismissal of unserved defendants under Rule 41(b) and Rule 4(m) while permitting claims against other defendants to continue.
- Issuing a service-cure order followed by an explicit order to show cause satisfies the requirement that a court explore less drastic alternatives before recommending involuntary dismissal.
- Under Ninth Circuit standards, a plaintiff's failure to cure deficient service or respond to court directives outweighs the general public policy favoring disposition on the merits.
- These findings and recommendations are not immediately final: under 28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(1), parties have 14 days after service to file written objections, and failure to object may waive appellate review of the district judge's final order.
Why It Matters
This decision highlights the interplay between Rule 41(b) failure-to-prosecute standards and Rule 4(m) service requirements in pro se in forma pauperis litigation. Even though the U.S. Marshal executes service for in forma pauperis litigants, the plaintiff retains the affirmative duty to provide accurate service information and comply with court orders to remedy defective service.
The ruling also underscores the advisory nature of magistrate judge findings and recommendations under 28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(1). Because the magistrate judge only recommends dismissal as to one defendant, the assigned district judge must review any objections before issuing an operative order, preserving the integrity of the remaining proceedings against the other named defendant.