Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Company sought a declaratory judgment that it owed no duty to defend or indemnify Franz Construction, Inc., Grizzly Coil Tubing Services, Inc., Don Franz, and Arlon Franz under its policies. The district court granted summary judgment for St. Paul, and the insureds appealed to the Ninth Circuit.
The appeal was submitted without oral argument before Circuit Judges McKeown, Desai, and De Alba. The panel reviewed the summary judgment ruling and the interpretation of Montana law and the insurance policies de novo, and exercised jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1291.
The Court’s Holding
The panel held that St. Paul had no duty to defend Don under the Franz Construction and Grizzly policies. The underlying complaint alleged intentional conduct—funding, assistance, and encouragement intended to facilitate Arlon's fraudulent conduct—and the policies covered only bodily injury or property damage caused by an "event," defined as an accident. Because the conduct was intentional and the takeover harm was objectively expected, it was not an accident under Montana law.
With no duty to defend, St. Paul could not have breached one, so the district court properly granted summary judgment. The panel also declined to consider a first-time-on-appeal challenge to summary judgment as to Franz Construction, noting in a footnote that appellants admitted St. Paul had no duty to defend that entity because the underlying action did not name it. The judgment was affirmed.
Key Takeaways
- Under Montana law, intentional conduct whose resulting harm is objectively expected falls outside policy coverage limited to accidents, even where the policy language could reach some intentional acts with unintended damage.
- An insurer cannot breach a duty to defend that never arose; where the underlying complaint establishes non-coverage, summary judgment for the insurer is proper.
- Arguments raised for the first time on appeal are generally waived, and an appellant's own concession that no defense duty existed independently supports affirmance as to that entity.
Why It Matters
This unpublished memorandum illustrates how intentional-tort allegations in an underlying complaint can eliminate a defense duty at the pleading-comparison stage under Montana's accident definition, sparing the insurer from coverage for an allegedly fraudulent business takeover.
The Franz Construction footnote reinforces both the waiver rule for new appellate arguments and the practical effect of party admissions in insurance appeals.