California Case Summaries

Sellars v. Rose — Anti-SLAPP Attorney Fee Lodestar Award Upheld Against Excessive Time and Rate Challenges

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Sellars v. Rose
Court
4th District Court of Appeal, Division Three
Judge
Scott (Gavin Newsom, 2025); Moore (Gray Davis, 2000); Servino
Date Decided
2026-11-10
Docket No.
G066255
Status
Unreported / Non-Citable
Topics
anti-SLAPP, attorney fees, lodestar calculation, reasonable hourly rates, Civil Code section 47.1, appellate attorney fees

Background

Plaintiffs John Sellars, Terri Sellars, and Christopher Sellars initiated a lawsuit alleging slander per se against defendant Karen Rose based on statements she made regarding plaintiffs during a 2024 podcast. In response to the complaint, Rose filed a special motion to strike under California's anti-SLAPP statute, Code of Civil Procedure section 425.16. The trial court granted Rose's anti-SLAPP motion to strike, concluding that the claims arose from protected speech and lacked the requisite probability of prevailing on the merits.

Following her success on the special motion to strike, Rose moved for a mandatory award of attorney fees and costs pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section 425.16, subdivision (c)(1). Rose requested a total of $342,523 in fees, which comprised $171,261.50 in baseline incurred attorney fees subject to a requested two-fold multiplier under Civil Code section 47.1. Plaintiffs contested the motion, challenging both the hourly rates and the overall hours billed by Rose's counsel, and submitted an itemized spreadsheet cataloging specific objections to defense counsel's billing entries.

The Orange County Superior Court, presided over by Judge Bradley Erdosi, granted the fee motion in part and denied it in part. The trial court determined that the claimed billing rates of $895 and $595 per hour were reasonable in light of counsels' experience, the contingent nature of the case, the legal market, and the nature of the action. While finding the majority of billing items withstood scrutiny, the court deducted $9,375.50 because some tasks were not properly related to the motion or too vaguely described to be attributed with any certainty to the anti-SLAPP motion, resulting in an established lodestar of $161,886.00, while denying the requested statutory multiplier. Plaintiffs appealed the resulting fee award.

The Court’s Holding

The Court of Appeal affirmed the order awarding Rose $161,886 in attorney fees and remanded the matter to the trial court to determine the amount of appellate attorney fees. Writing for the panel, the court reiterated that fee determinations under the anti-SLAPP statute are reviewed under the highly deferential abuse of discretion standard, as the trial judge is in the best position to assess the value and necessity of professional services rendered in the trial court proceedings.

The appellate court rejected plaintiffs' challenge to the prevailing hourly rates of $595 and $895, noting that the rates were properly substantiated by attorney declarations that the appellate court could not reweigh. Given counsel's litigation background, the legal community in Orange County, and a recent malicious prosecution case in which this court affirmed hourly rates ranging from $550 to $975, the rates were not manifestly excessive or outside the realm of reasonable local billing practices.

The court also rejected plaintiffs' assertion that spending 223.7 hours across two partners and an associate was excessive as a matter of law. The trial court had already trimmed unsupported entries, and no formal statement of decision was required. In addition, the anti-SLAPP motion tackled an issue of first impression concerning the newly enacted Civil Code section 47.1, and the companion published decision affirmed the trial court's order granting the anti-SLAPP motion, which reasonably justified the depth and complexity of counsel's preparation and strategic consultations.

Key Takeaways

  • Mandatory attorney fee awards under California's anti-SLAPP statute are reviewed strictly for abuse of discretion and will not be disturbed absent a showing that the award is manifestly excessive.
  • Trial courts need not provide a formal statement of decision or itemized entry-by-entry breakdown when calculating or slightly trimming a lodestar fee submission.
  • Hourly billing rates between $595 and $895 for experienced litigators are supported by the prevailing legal market in Orange County for complex anti-SLAPP litigation.
  • Extensive attorney hours spent investigating factual predicates, listening to source material like podcasts, and conferring on strategy are compensable when reasonably tied to anti-SLAPP motion preparation.
  • A prevailing defendant who successfully defends an anti-SLAPP fee award on appeal is statutorily entitled to recover additional appellate attorney fees.

Why It Matters

This decision underscores the robust deference California appellate courts accord to trial judges in calculating lodestar figures under Code of Civil Procedure section 425.16. By rejecting rigid caps on the time needed to brief anti-SLAPP motions, the opinion confirms that the presence of novel statutory questions—such as newly enacted provisions like Civil Code section 47.1—can reasonably warrant substantial attorney investment and justify significant fee awards.

Litigants challenging fee petitions in the Fourth Appellate District must present concrete proof that awarded rates or tasks fall outside the local community norms, rather than merely submitting extensive line-item objections or citing inapplicable unapproved billing rates from prior decisions.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top