Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Ronald Eugene James, a prisoner proceeding pro se, sued Richardson and other defendants under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 in the Eastern District of California (No. 2:23-cv-0853). The court had earlier given defendants leave to depose him by video conference (ECF No. 34).
Defendants noticed his remote deposition on March 3, 2026, for March 26, 2026. James appeared by Zoom but refused to answer questions, stating that he would appear only for an in-person deposition. Defendants moved to compel his deposition and to modify the scheduling order, and James opposed.
James separately moved to reopen discovery (ECF No. 56) and to compel defendants to answer and produce on his discovery requests (ECF No. 58). Defendants objected that discovery had closed on March 27, 2026, and that requests had to be served 60 days earlier. James signed his requests on February 3, 2026, but defendants said they were not served until March 3, 2026.
The Court’s Holding
The court granted defendants' motion to compel. It found that James's failure to answer questions at a properly noticed deposition violated the scheduling order. It ordered him to appear at a properly noticed deposition, which may be conducted remotely. It cited Rule 37 and the court's broad discretion to manage discovery under Rule 16.
The court also granted James's motion to reopen discovery, but only as to the discovery requests he had already provided, and granted his motion to compel documents and interrogatory responses. It cited the Ninth Circuit's instruction to construe pro se prisoner filings liberally and the prisoner mailbox rule. Because James signed his proof of service while incarcerated on February 3, 2026, and noted the difficulty of making copies while the prison law library was closed, the court ruled that his non-compliance with the strict terms of the scheduling order should not defeat his discovery requests.
The order allows discovery until February 24, 2027, limited to the deposition, interrogatories, and document production previously requested, and sets May 25, 2027 as the dispositive-motion deadline. It does not decide James's preliminary injunction motion (ECF No. 52), which the court said will be addressed by separate findings and recommendations.
Key Takeaways
- A prisoner plaintiff who appears for a court-authorized remote deposition but refuses to answer because he wants an in-person session can be ordered to appear at a properly noticed deposition, which may be conducted remotely.
- The court treated the prisoner mailbox rule and liberal construction of pro se filings as reasons not to let non-compliance with the scheduling order defeat James's late-served discovery requests.
- The reopening is narrow: discovery covers only the deposition and the requests James had already made, not new rounds.
- The order sets a new discovery cutoff of February 24, 2027 and a dispositive-motion deadline of May 25, 2027.
- The preliminary injunction motion is not resolved in this order and is left for separate findings and recommendations.
Why It Matters
The ruling shows a magistrate judge enforcing a prior scheduling order against a pro se prisoner while excusing the timing of his discovery requests, relying on the mailbox rule and the prison's limited copying access.
Because the court limited reopened discovery to previously served requests and the deposition, it gives both sides what they need without opening a new, unlimited discovery period. It is a case-management order and not a merits ruling on James's claims.