California Case Summaries

Rene Aparicio et al. v. Real Time Resolutions, Inc. et al. — Failure to Oppose Motion to Dismiss Results in Dismissal With Prejudice Under Local Rule 7-12

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Rene Aparicio et al. v. Real Time Resolutions, Inc. et al.
Court
U.S. District Court — Central District of California
Judge
Otis D. Wright II (George W. Bush, 2007)
Date Decided
2026-11-10
Docket No.
2:26-cv-07287
Status
Unreported
Topics
unopposed motion to dismiss, Local Rule 7-12, dismissal with prejudice, failure to prosecute, Ninth Circuit Ghazali factors

Background

Plaintiffs Rene Aparicio and Caridad Paniagua initiated this action against Real Time Resolutions, Inc. and other defendants in the Central District of California. After commencing the lawsuit, Plaintiffs actively litigated the matter, filing a First Amended Complaint on August 12, 2026, and subsequently entering into a stipulation to extend Defendant's deadline to answer or otherwise respond to the operative pleading.

Defendant Real Time Resolutions, Inc. subsequently filed a motion to dismiss the First Amended Complaint with prejudice. The hearing on Defendant's motion was calendared for November 16, 2026. Under Central District of California Local Rule 7-9, Plaintiffs were required to file an opposition to the motion at least twenty-one days prior to the designated hearing date, establishing an opposition deadline of October 26, 2026.

Plaintiffs failed to file an opposition by the deadline, nor did they submit any request for an extension of time or a continuance. Finding the matter suitable for resolution without oral argument, the district court vacated the scheduled hearing pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 78(b) and Local Rule 7-15 to resolve the unopposed motion.

The Court’s Holding

The district court granted Defendant's motion to dismiss and dismissed Plaintiffs' First Amended Complaint with prejudice. Under Central District of California Local Rule 7-12, the failure to timely file a required paper may be deemed consent to the granting of the motion. Before dismissing an action under a local rule, the court evaluated the five factors articulated by the Ninth Circuit in Ghazali v. Moran: the public interest in expeditious resolution, docket management needs, the risk of prejudice to defendants, public policy favoring disposition on the merits, and the availability of less drastic measures.

The court concluded that the Ghazali balancing factors favored dismissal. The court specifically observed that Plaintiffs had previously demonstrated active participation in the litigation by filing an amended complaint and executing a scheduling stipulation, yet they completely failed to file an opposition or seek a continuance regarding the pending motion to dismiss. Consequently, the court deemed Plaintiffs' failure to respond as consent to granting the motion under Local Rule 7-12 and ordered dismissal with prejudice.

Key Takeaways

  • Litigants in the Central District of California must strictly observe Local Rule 7-9's 21-day opposition deadline, as Local Rule 7-12 empowers the court to construe non-opposition as consent to granting the motion.
  • Dismissal under local procedural rules requires consideration of the Ninth Circuit's five-factor test from Ghazali v. Moran, though the district court is not required to make explicit written findings on each factor.
  • Prior active participation in a case will not shield a party from dismissal with prejudice if that party completely fails to oppose a dispositive motion or seek an extension of time.

Why It Matters

This decision underscores the strict enforceability of local motion practice deadlines in federal court, highlighting that non-responsiveness to a motion to dismiss can lead directly to termination of the litigation on the merits with prejudice rather than a dismissal with leave to amend.

It also illustrates the practical application of Ninth Circuit precedent regarding local rule dismissals, demonstrating that courts will balance docket-management and expedition concerns against the policy favoring merits decisions when a party appears to have abandoned the defense of its claims.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top