Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Plaintiff Oscar Magallanes filed a civil complaint against Bougie Beach Collective LLC and other defendants in the United States District Court for the Central District of California. The complaint asserted federal claims under the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA), 42 U.S.C. § 12101 et seq., alongside state-law claims under the California Unruh Civil Rights Act, California Civil Code §§ 51–52, and related provisions. Magallanes invoked federal supplemental jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1367(a) as the basis for bringing his state-law claims in federal court.
Screening the complaint, the court noted that California has enacted specialized statutory reforms to regulate construction-related accessibility lawsuits. In 2012, California imposed heightened pleading requirements under California Civil Code § 55.52(a)(1) and California Code of Civil Procedure § 425.50(a). In 2015, the legislature enacted a high-frequency litigant fee under California Government Code § 70616.5 for claimants and law firms filing numerous accessibility suits. As prior Central District decisions recognized, these statutes address the small group of frequent filers who generate a large proportion of accessibility litigation.
A docket check revealed that Magallanes had filed more than ten actions asserting construction-related accessibility claims in the Central District during the preceding year. In state court, Magallanes would be classified as a high-frequency litigant subject to heightened procedural rules and fees. Because exercising supplemental jurisdiction allows high-frequency plaintiffs to sidestep state requirements in federal court, judges in the district frequently decline jurisdiction to respect California's substantial interest in regulating these disputes.
The Court’s Holding
Judge John A. Kronstadt ordered Magallanes to show cause why the court should not decline supplemental jurisdiction over the state-law claims under 28 U.S.C. § 1367(c). The court observed that supplemental jurisdiction is a doctrine of discretion rather than a plaintiff's right under United Mine Workers v. Gibbs. Under Ninth Circuit precedent in Nishimoto v. Federman-Bachrach & Associates, district courts must assess judicial economy, convenience, fairness, and comity at every litigation stage when deciding whether to exercise jurisdiction over pendent state claims.
The court directed Magallanes to file a written response of no more than ten pages by December 1, 2026. In his response, Magallanes must identify the precise amount of statutory damages he seeks to recover. Furthermore, the court required Magallanes to submit an evidentiary declaration signed under penalty of perjury providing facts necessary to determine whether he meets the definition of a high-frequency litigant under California Code of Civil Procedure § 425.50(b)(1) and (2).
Judge Kronstadt warned that failing to file a timely response could result in dismissal of the state-law claims without prejudice under 28 U.S.C. § 1367(c). The order also permitted defendants to file a response not exceeding ten pages on or before December 8, 2028. After receiving the responses, the court will take the matter under submission and issue a written order resolving the supplemental jurisdiction issue.
Key Takeaways
- Federal courts in California routinely conduct sua sponte screening of construction-related accessibility suits to prevent evasion of state statutory requirements.
- Filing more than ten accessibility lawsuits in one year triggers presumptive status as a high-frequency litigant under California law.
- A plaintiff ordered to show cause must submit a sworn declaration detailing litigation history and specifying the precise statutory damages requested.
- Failure to satisfy the show-cause order risks dismissal of all pendent state-law claims without prejudice under 28 U.S.C. § 1367(c).
- District courts prioritize comity and judicial economy over supplemental jurisdiction when federal forums are used to bypass state procedural reforms.
Why It Matters
This decision demonstrates the continued vigilance of California federal courts in addressing serial disability accessibility litigation. By enacting heightened pleading rules and high-frequency filing fees, California sought to balance public accommodation enforcement with protections against abusive litigation. When plaintiffs file companion Unruh Act claims in federal court alongside federal ADA claims, they often seek statutory damages unavailable under federal law while sidestepping state-mandated filings and fees. Judge Kronstadt's order reflects the district's consistent practice of using supplemental jurisdiction screening to safeguard state policy and comity.
For practitioners and litigants, the order underscores that serial ADA litigation in federal court will encounter early judicial resistance regarding state-law remedies. Plaintiffs' counsel must be prepared to disclose litigation metrics under penalty of perjury and justify why comity does not require dismissal of pendent claims. For business defendants, the ruling highlights an effective avenue to eliminate state statutory damages exposure early in the proceeding, narrowing the federal action to injunctive relief under the ADA.