California Case Summaries

Matthew James Hollis v. Joshua Thomas Patton, et al. — Magistrate judge denies pro se plaintiff’s service, default, and sanctions motions, orders 30-day service extension, and recommends partial dismissal with leave to amend

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Matthew James Hollis v. Joshua Thomas Patton, et al.
Court
U.S. District Court — Eastern District of California
Judge
Sean C. Riordan (U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California, by Chief Judge Kimberly J. Mueller, 2024)
Date Decided
2026-11-20
Docket No.
2:26-cv-01658
Status
Unreported
Topics
service of process, default entry, sanctions, sovereign immunity, Rooker-Feldman doctrine, judicial immunity, Rule 8 pleading, Monell liability

Background

Plaintiff Matthew James Hollis, proceeding pro se, filed this civil action in December 2025 alleging unlawful surveillance and fraudulent legal proceedings arising from the dissolution of a romantic relationship with California State Parks peace officer Joshua Thomas Patton. The 141-page complaint asserted claims under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, RICO, and state law against Patton, court-appointed mediator Stephen Wattenberg, Riverside County deputy Matthew Looney, Butte County, the California Department of Parks and Recreation (CDPR), CDPR Director Armando Quintero, and Butte County Superior Court Commissioner Mark Alexander Emmons.

Following transfer to the Eastern District of California due to improper venue, nine motions were pending: four motions to dismiss, a motion to quash service, plaintiff's renewed motion for Marshal service, two requests for entry of default, and a motion for 28 U.S.C. § 1927 sanctions. The magistrate judge heard argument on eight motions on September 10, 2026, and submitted Butte County's motion to dismiss on the briefs.

The magistrate judge denied plaintiff's four motions. The court found no good cause for Marshal service because plaintiff was not proceeding in forma pauperis and private service remained feasible, though it directed counsel for Riverside County to provide an email address for Looney and allowed plaintiff to serve Looney by email. The court also declined to enter default against Emmons and Wattenberg because both had appeared and were defending, and found no subjective bad faith supporting sanctions against defense counsel.

The Court’s Holding

On the service-related motions, the court found Patton was properly served under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4(e)(2)(B) by leaving process with his father at Patton's dwelling, recommending denial of the motion to dismiss as to Patton. However, the court recommended granting in part the motion as to Quintero because plaintiff failed to serve the Department of Natural Resources alongside the Attorney General, while sua sponte extending service time by 30 days. The court also recommended granting Wattenberg's motion to quash for improper service on county and state officials, extending time by 30 days to effect personal service or service on the superior court executive officer under California Government Code § 955.9(a), with substitute email service authorized if personal service fails.

On the substantive motions to dismiss, the magistrate judge recommended dismissing CDPR and Butte County without leave to amend. Sovereign immunity barred all § 1983 and RICO claims against CDPR, and Butte County could not face Monell or respondeat superior liability for the judicial acts of the superior court, which functions as an arm of the state. The court recommended granting Commissioner Emmons's motion to dismiss based on Rooker-Feldman and absolute judicial immunity because plaintiff collaterally attacked a state restraining order, but recommended granting leave to amend. The court further recommended dismissing Count IV without leave to amend as to all defendants because 18 U.S.C. § 1512 provides no private right of action.

By operative order, the court denied plaintiff's motions, ordered Patton to respond within 14 days, and granted 30 days to complete service on Wattenberg, Looney, and Quintero. The magistrate judge recommended granting plaintiff 30 days to file a first amended complaint regarding remaining claims and defendants, submitting the recommendations to the assigned district judge with a 14-day objection deadline.

Key Takeaways

  • Service of process on an individual under Rule 4(e)(2)(B) is valid when left at the defendant's dwelling with a resident of suitable age and discretion, even if the defendant disputes receipt.
  • State agencies retain Eleventh Amendment immunity against § 1983 and RICO claims for damages and injunctive relief, rendering amendment futile where sovereign immunity applies.
  • A municipal county cannot be held liable under Monell or respondeat superior for the judicial or administrative acts of a California superior court, which functions as an arm of the state.
  • The Rooker-Feldman doctrine and absolute judicial immunity bar federal civil suits seeking to overturn, expunge, or enjoin state-court restraining orders and challenging judicial rulings.
  • Claims asserting a private right of action under the federal criminal witness-tampering statute, 18 U.S.C. § 1512, fail as a matter of law and must be dismissed with prejudice.

Why It Matters

This decision underscores the jurisdictional barriers pro se litigants face when attempting to challenge state-court domestic relations and restraining orders in federal court under § 1983 and RICO, demonstrating that judicial immunity and the Rooker-Feldman doctrine preclude collateral attacks on state-court proceedings.

The ruling also provides practical guidance on California service rules in federal court, affirming abode service on co-resident family members, enforcing strict statutory requirements for serving judicial and state agency personnel, and authorizing electronic substitute service where traditional personal service is obstructed.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top