Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Plaintiff Joseph Anthony Reyna, proceeding pro se and in forma pauperis, alleges that Nissan North America, Inc. discriminated against him on the basis of his disability, attention deficit disorder, by calling him about a car warranty claim after he had asked that Nissan communicate with him only in writing. He brings claims under the Americans with Disabilities Act and several California antidiscrimination statutes.
The court recounted that Reyna resides in Austin, Texas, while Nissan is incorporated in Delaware and headquartered in Franklin, Tennessee. None of the events alleged in the First Amended Complaint occurred in California; the vehicle failure and the July 8, 2025 phone call all appear to have happened in or near Austin, Texas.
Nissan moved to dismiss for improper venue under 28 U.S.C. § 1406(a), to transfer under § 1404(a), or alternatively to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6). The court declined to consider Reyna's proposed sur-reply and denied his requests for judicial notice as irrelevant to the motion.
The Court’s Holding
The court found no basis to maintain venue in the Northern District of California. Neither party resided in California and no part of the alleged conduct occurred there, and Reyna identified no contacts between himself and any California Nissan dealership or agent.
The court concluded that Plaintiff had not established personal jurisdiction over Nissan in California. It stated that it had no general jurisdiction because Nissan was neither incorporated nor headquartered in the state, and no specific jurisdiction because none of the events underlying the claims arose out of or related to Nissan's forum-related activities. Allegations about Nissan's California dealership network and telephone system did not connect California operations to the challenged phone call.
Because Reyna lived in the Western District of Texas and the events occurred there, the court found venue proper there and that forum most convenient, with Texas having the greater interest in the dispute. It transferred the action in the interest of justice and did not reach Nissan's Rule 12(b)(6) motion.
Key Takeaways
- A plaintiff cannot establish venue based solely on a defendant's general business presence in the forum when neither the parties nor the operative events have any connection to that forum.
- Allegations that a national company operates dealerships and a customer-service telephone system in California do not, without more, link California operations to alleged discriminatory conduct occurring in Texas.
- A court may conclude that a plaintiff has failed to establish personal jurisdiction without making an affirmative finding of no jurisdiction, and may alternatively transfer under § 1404(a) when convenience and the interest of justice favor the plaintiff's home forum.
- Transfer rather than dismissal serves the interest of justice where the action could have been brought in the transferee district.
Why It Matters
The order illustrates the limits of venue based on corporate presence: generalized allegations about a defendant's in-state dealerships and telephone infrastructure cannot substitute for a concrete connection between the forum and the plaintiff's claims.
The court's footnote 3 addressed a split over whether failing to raise personal jurisdiction alongside a venue challenge waives the objection. It read Nissan's briefing as objecting to both and treated any omission as harmless, while preserving § 1404(a) discretionary transfer as an alternative ground.