Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Plaintiffs filed five state-law claims against Flock Group Inc. in Contra Costa County Superior Court, including claims under California's automated license plate reader statute and a state constitutional privacy claim. Flock removed the putative class action to federal court under the Class Action Fairness Act and moved to dismiss the consolidated complaint.
At the motion hearing, the court questioned whether plaintiffs had Article III standing to pursue their first four statutory claims. The parties agreed that if the court found no standing on those claims, it would remand without deciding the fifth claim.
The Court’s Holding
On the theory that Flock harmed plaintiffs by collecting and compiling their ALPR data into searchable dossiers, the court found no traceability. Claims 1 and 3 challenged only Flock's alleged failure to implement a compliant privacy policy and reasonable security procedures, but the asserted privacy harm flowed from Flock's data collection and compilation, which California's ALPR statute does not itself prohibit.
On the theory that sharing data with out-of-state and federal agencies caused a discrete privacy injury, the court found no concrete Article III harm. The distinction between in-state and out-of-state recipients exists only because of the statute, and plaintiffs did not show an injury independent of the alleged statutory violation. Because the parties stipulated to remand if Claims 1 through 4 lacked standing, the court did not reach the California constitutional privacy claim and remanded to the Contra Costa County Superior Court.
Key Takeaways
- Alleged violations of procedural safeguards in California's ALPR statute were not fairly traceable to a privacy harm caused by Flock's data collection and compilation, which the statute does not prohibit.
- A statutory distinction between authorized and unauthorized data recipients does not by itself create a concrete Article III injury independent of the statutory violation.
- Under the parties' stipulation, the court remanded without deciding standing on the California constitutional privacy claim.
Why It Matters
The ruling illustrates the standing barrier for state statutory privacy claims in federal court: plaintiffs must connect the challenged statutory duty to a concrete, traceable injury rather than rely on the statutory prohibition alone.
The order also enforces a negotiated procedural bargain, remanding the entire case once standing failed on the first four claims and leaving the state-law privacy claim for the state court.