California Case Summaries

Garred Farrell Norman v. U.S. Department of Justice, et al. — Pro Se FOIA Action Dismissed Without Prejudice for Failure to Serve Under Rules 4(m) and 41(b)

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Garred Farrell Norman v. U.S. Department of Justice, et al.
Court
U.S. District Court — Northern District of California
Judge
JACQUELINE SCOTT CORLEY (Joseph R. Biden, 2022)
Date Decided
2026-10-07
Docket No.
3:26-cv-04015
Status
Unreported
Topics
Freedom of Information Act, Rule 4(m) service of process, Rule 41(b) failure to prosecute, Henderson dismissal factors, pro se litigant, dismissal without prejudice

Background

Norman, representing himself, filed suit in the Northern District of California against the U.S. Department of Justice and other entities under the Freedom of Information Act. By order filed July 31, 2026, the court reminded him that he was responsible for serving the defendants with the summons and complaint within the time allowed by Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4(m). The court later extended the deadline to October 1, 2026, while warning that the case would be dismissed without prejudice if proofs of service were not filed by that date.

Although Norman filed proof-of-service forms, the forms showed that he had personally served the defendants himself, which Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4(c)(2) does not permit. The court specifically advised him that he could not personally serve the defendants and told him he could contact the district's Legal Help Desk. Instead of arranging proper service, Norman filed two summary-judgment motions, which the court dismissed without prejudice, and pursued three appeals to the Ninth Circuit. To date, no proof of proper service on any defendant had been filed.

The Court’s Holding

The court dismissed the action without prejudice under Rule 4(m). The quoted rule allows dismissal without prejudice or an order that service be made within a specified time when a defendant is not served within 90 days after the complaint is filed; here, the court had extended time and warned Norman, yet he still had not filed proof of proper service on any defendant despite multiple extensions.

The court also found dismissal independently warranted under Rule 41(b) for failure to prosecute and failure to comply with court orders, applying the five Henderson factors: expeditious resolution, docket management, prejudice to defendants, the merits policy, and less drastic sanctions. Four factors weighed in favor of dismissal: the first two because Norman's noncompliance and improper filings delayed adjudication; the third because, although pendency alone was not sufficiently prejudicial, the delay caused by his failure to prosecute despite court orders weighed in favor of dismissal; and the fourth because the court had already extended deadlines and repeatedly warned that dismissal would follow. Only the public policy favoring disposition on the merits weighed against dismissal, and the court held that four factors strongly supporting dismissal sufficed.

Key Takeaways

  • A party cannot personally serve the summons and complaint in his own case; Rule 4(c)(2) requires service by a nonparty, and proof-of-service forms showing self-service do not establish proper service under Rule 4(m).
  • Rule 4(m) does not mechanically require dismissal the moment 90 days pass; it also permits the court to order service within a specified time, and here the court used extensions and warnings before dismissing.
  • Courts may dismiss sua sponte under Rule 41(b) for failure to prosecute or to obey orders, but Ninth Circuit law requires weighing the Henderson factors and, in this order, four of five factors strongly supported dismissal.
  • Repeated warnings that dismissal will follow can satisfy the less-drastic-sanctions factor, especially when the court has already extended deadlines and referred the plaintiff to legal help resources.
  • Because the dismissal was without prejudice, the court adjudicated no FOIA merits issues, and Norman remains free to refile only if he can effect proper service.

Why It Matters

The order shows how a district court applies the Ninth Circuit's Henderson framework when a self-represented plaintiff persistently fails to complete service despite extensions, explicit warnings, and referral to the Legal Help Desk. It confirms that prior warnings can satisfy the obligation to consider less drastic sanctions before dismissal.

It also underscores the limited scope of the ruling: dismissal without prejudice for defective service leaves the underlying FOIA claims untouched and disposes of the case purely on procedural grounds.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top