Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Alexander Garcia hosted a social running group called Tuesday Waterfront Run (TWR), which James Ades joined in 2022. Following complaints regarding Ades's interactions with members and an impromptu speech discussing an affair with a member, Garcia informed Ades he was unwelcome. When Ades returned to runs in March 2024 despite warnings, Garcia publicly asked participants to ignore him, prompting Ades to sue Garcia for defamation in small claims court.
In June 2024, Garcia petitioned for a civil harassment restraining order under Code of Civil Procedure section 527.6. During an evidentiary hearing break, the parties reached an informal agreement on the record: Garcia agreed to dismiss the petition without prejudice, and Ades agreed to avoid TWR events for one year, refrain from contacting Garcia, and stay away in public. Ades subsequently moved for $9,193.30 in attorney's fees under section 527.6, subdivision (s), arguing that the dismissal made him the prevailing party. The trial court denied the motion as untimely, procedurally defective, and unwarranted because the matter ended in a settlement.
The Court’s Holding
The Fourth District Court of Appeal affirmed, holding that the trial court acted within its broad discretion in determining Ades was not the prevailing party on a practical level. Although the trial court overstated the governing standard by suggesting Ades had to show something 'out of the ordinary' or bad faith to receive fees under section 527.6, subdivision (s), that error was harmless because the court correctly recognized that fee entitlement turned on whether Ades actually prevailed.
The court rejected Ades's contention that a voluntary dismissal automatically confers prevailing party status under the general cost provisions of Code of Civil Procedure section 1032, subdivision (a)(4). Prevailing party status under section 527.6 is determined on a practical level based on whether a party achieved their litigation objectives. Because Garcia secured a binding courtroom commitment that Ades would stay away and avoid contact, the dismissal resulted from a mutual compromise rather than a defense victory on the merits.
Key Takeaways
- A voluntary dismissal without prejudice does not automatically make a defendant the prevailing party for attorney's fees under Code of Civil Procedure section 527.6, subdivision (s).
- Prevailing party status under section 527.6 is evaluated on a practical level based on whether a litigant achieved their core litigation objectives.
- A restraining order petitioner obtains meaningful practical relief when a respondent agrees on the record to stay away and avoid contact.
- A trial court's reservation of jurisdiction over a noticed fee motion does not indicate or imply that the contemplated motion has legal merit.
Why It Matters
This decision confirms that general cost definitions under section 1032 do not control discretionary attorney fee awards under Code of Civil Procedure section 527.6. When civil harassment litigation ends in an informal courtroom compromise or stay-away agreement, respondents cannot convert resulting dismissals into fee awards, and trial court fee denials will stand where the record demonstrates that neither party prevailed as a practical matter.