California Case Summaries

Edward Roy Welch v. B. Mayberry, et al. — Court denies prisoner’s motion to attach a due-process claim over allegedly false incident reports and gives him thirty days to elect between proceeding on excessive force or filing a complete amended complaint

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Edward Roy Welch v. B. Mayberry, et al.
Court
U.S. District Court — Eastern District of California
Judge
Chi Soo Kim (magistrate judge)
Date Decided
2026-11-10
Docket No.
2:26-cv-00407
Status
Unreported
Topics
prisoner civil rights, Section 1983, excessive force, due process, false incident reports, amended complaint, screening, notice of election, pro se litigation

Background

Edward Roy Welch, appearing pro se and in forma pauperis, sued seven Mule Creek State Prison correctional officers under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 in the Eastern District of California: B. Mayberry, J. Boyle, N. Lindsay, S. Young, J. Williams, R. Villareal and P. Goytia. The case was referred to a United States Magistrate Judge under 28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(1)(B) and Local Rule 302. Magistrate Judge Chi Soo Kim signed the November 10, 2026 order, according to the docket entry.

On May 6, 2026, the court screened the complaint and gave Welch thirty days to elect between proceeding solely on his excessive-force claim against Mayberry and filing an amended complaint to try to state claims against the other defendants. Welch opted to amend and, after a sixty-day extension granted June 18, filed a motion on August 21, 2026. It asked the court to file 'claim II' attached to 'claim I' rather than as a standalone claim.

The court read the motion as an attempt to add material to the original complaint and as disagreement with the screening order. Welch objected that the defendants lied in the excessive-force incident report, not only in a later rules violation report that was dismissed, and said this violated his due-process rights.

The Court’s Holding

The court held that it made no difference whether defendants allegedly lied in the incident report or the rules violation report, because neither allegation is a standalone due-process violation. It cited Evans v. Flores and Coria v. Garcia for the principle that there is no constitutional immunity from being falsely accused of conduct that may lead to loss of a protected liberty interest.

The court said the statements in the incident report remain relevant to the excessive-force claim against Mayberry, but they do not support a separate due-process claim. Welch need not name the other officers as defendants to challenge those statements, and the allegations do not show that any of them used excessive force, as the screening order had explained.

The motion also failed because it could not serve as an amended complaint. Under Local Rule 220 and Ramirez v. County of San Bernardino, an amended complaint must be complete in itself and supersedes the original. The court denied the motion and gave Welch thirty days to file the appended Notice of Election form, either proceeding solely on the Eighth Amendment excessive-force claim against Mayberry or submitting a complete amended complaint with the form. It warned that failure to comply will result in a recommendation that the action be dismissed. The order does not itself dismiss anything.

Key Takeaways

  • Allegations that officers wrote false incident or disciplinary reports do not by themselves state a standalone due-process claim under Section 1983.
  • A plaintiff cannot amend a complaint by motion or by asking the court to attach new claims; an amended complaint must be complete in itself under Local Rule 220.
  • Statements in an incident report may still be relevant to an excessive-force claim, and the reporting officers need not be named as defendants to challenge them.
  • Noncompliance with the thirty-day election deadline will lead to a recommendation of dismissal, not an immediate dismissal.

Why It Matters

The order shows how screening practice separates evidence from causes of action in prisoner litigation. Allegations of false reports may bear on a surviving excessive-force claim even though they cannot support an independent constitutional claim against the officers who wrote them.

It also shows that courts apply pleading formalities to pro se prisoners and will not rewrite complaints piecemeal. The plaintiff must either narrow the case to the potentially cognizable claim or file a self-contained amended pleading by the deadline.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top