Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Candace Thomas worked for General Atomics, Inc. for over seventeen years, advancing to Program Manager in a hybrid role with minimal travel where duties were primarily computer-based and conducted remotely. After taking medical leave for degenerative disc disease, Thomas requested telework as a reasonable accommodation in May 2025. General Atomics denied the accommodation and ordered her to report onsite in Poway, California. Around the same time, Thomas submitted an internal ethics complaint regarding government contract charging practices. When Thomas did not report onsite, General Atomics placed her on unpaid administrative leave on July 31, 2025, and revoked her systems access.
Thomas sued in California state court alleging disability discrimination, failure to accommodate, and retaliation under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), the California Family Rights Act (CFRA), and California Labor Code section 1102.5. After removal based on federal question jurisdiction, Thomas amended her complaint to delete all federal claims. In response to the district court's order to show cause regarding subject matter jurisdiction, General Atomics established diversity jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1332 by showing diverse citizenship—Thomas had relocated to North Carolina while General Atomics was a California citizen—and lost wages exceeding $75,000.
The Court’s Holding
The district court granted General Atomics's motion to dismiss the First Amended Complaint, holding that Thomas failed to plead facts sufficient to overcome California's presumption against extraterritorial statutory application. Extraterritorial application of FEHA, CFRA, and Labor Code section 1102.5 requires establishing that California was either the employee's situs of employment or the situs of the material elements of the claims. The court held that Thomas's allegation of employment in Poway was merely conclusory because she lived in North Carolina, worked predominantly remotely, and collaborated with geographically dispersed teams.
The court also held that Thomas failed to establish a California situs for the alleged wrongful acts. The complaint did not identify where decisionmakers were physically located when denying her accommodation or imposing unpaid leave, where Thomas was located when injured, or specific conduct by named leadership. Rejecting Thomas's contention that requiring these jurisdictional facts creates an improper heightened pleading standard under Rule 8, the court dismissed all claims without prejudice and granted thirty days' leave to amend under Rule 15(a).
Key Takeaways
- California employment statutes, including FEHA, CFRA, and Labor Code section 1102.5, are presumed not to apply extraterritorially to out-of-state workers without specific factual ties establishing a California situs of employment or conduct.
- Conclusory assertions of California employment do not overcome Rule 12(b)(6) scrutiny when the plaintiff resides out of state and works predominantly remotely.
- To establish a California situs of wrongful conduct, a remote worker must plead specific facts showing where decisionmakers acted and where the employee suffered harm.
- Dismissal was entered without prejudice with thirty days' leave to amend under Rule 15(a)'s liberal standard to allow the plaintiff an opportunity to cure territorial pleading deficiencies.
Why It Matters
This decision underscores the stringent pleading requirements confronting remote and hybrid employees who reside outside California but seek protection under California's worker-friendly statutes. Out-of-state plaintiffs must allege concrete geographic facts tying adverse managerial decisions or employment operations to California rather than relying on general assertions of corporate headquarters oversight.