California Case Summaries

Smith v. Apria Healthcare — Proposed Interveners’ Challenge to Class Settlement Was Properly Denied as Untimely Where They Knew of Measurable Risk Months Before Seeking Intervention

Reported / Citable

Case
Smith v. Apria Healthcare
Court
3rd District Court of Appeal
Judge
Renner (Jerry Brown, 2014); Mesiwala (Gavin Newsom, 2023); Wiseman
Date Decided
2026-11-09
Docket No.
C104113
Status
Reported / Citable
Topics
class action settlement, intervention as of right, permissive intervention, timeliness, reverse auction, wage and hour claims

Background

Defendant Apria Healthcare LLC delivers home healthcare products through couriers contracted from staffing agencies and provides services via licensed vocational nurses. Travis Smith brought a representative Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA) action against Apria in Sutter County Superior Court after dismissing a putative class complaint. Meanwhile, in a separate Los Angeles County class action, Quintero v. Apria Healthcare LLC, delivery drivers achieved class certification and defeated arbitration. In June 2024, Smith and Apria accepted a mediator's proposal to settle. Shortly thereafter, Angela Tisdale and Terrance Pratt, represented by Quintero counsel, filed a follow-on courier class action in Los Angeles County Superior Court.

Apria provided Smith's counsel with courier Uriel Arauz's contact details, and the parties stipulated to amend the Sutter County complaint to add Arauz and courier class claims. In October 2024, Tisdale and Pratt opposed Apria's request for a stay in Los Angeles County Superior Court, warning that Apria sought to rush a collusive reverse auction settlement in Smith. Apria removed the Tisdale action to federal court in November 2024. In late March 2025, Smith and Apria executed a joint settlement allocating $977,500 of a $5.75 million sum to couriers, which the trial court preliminarily approved in April 2025 (entered April 21, 2025, though referenced as April 21, 2024, at line 8.12 of the opinion).

On May 8, 2025, after class notice was sent, Tisdale and Pratt filed an ex parte application to intervene under Code of Civil Procedure section 387, asserting the settlement was an unfair reverse auction. The Sutter County Superior Court found the interveners had adequate notice and presented only conjecture, entering an order on June 6, 2025, denying the substantive motion to intervene. Tisdale and Pratt appealed.

The Court’s Holding

As a threshold matter, the Third District Court of Appeal denied Apria's motion to dismiss the appeal as moot. Although final judgment was entered and settlement proceeds distributed after Tisdale and Pratt opted out, the 1977 amendment to Code of Civil Procedure section 387 permits intervention upon timely application even postjudgment. Additionally, a separate appeal from an order denying a motion to vacate the judgment by another class member left open an avenue for potential relief should that judgment be reversed.

On the merits, the court affirmed the denial of intervention, reviewing the trial court's implied finding of untimeliness for abuse of discretion. Timeliness under section 387 is determined by the totality of circumstances, focusing on the stage of the proceeding, prejudice to other parties, and the reason for delay. The court stressed that timeliness is measured from the date applicants knew or should have known their interests were not being adequately protected, rather than when they received precise settlement terms. The record established that Tisdale and Pratt knew their interests were imperiled no later than October 15, 2024, when their counsel expressed grave concerns regarding an alleged reverse auction.

Evaluating the three factors, the court concluded all weighed against intervention. The application was filed at an advanced stage after preliminary approval and class notice; intervention would prejudice settling parties by undoing months of litigation efforts; and the applicants offered no justification for waiting more than six months after recognizing measurable risk. Because timeliness is an indispensable prerequisite for both mandatory and permissive intervention, the denial was affirmed.

Key Takeaways

  • Timeliness is a mandatory prerequisite under Code of Civil Procedure section 387 for both intervention as of right and permissive intervention.
  • The timeliness clock begins when a proposed intervener knows or has reason to know that its interests are imperiled, not when exact settlement terms are disclosed.
  • An appeal from the denial of intervention is not rendered moot by postjudgment settlement distributions when a separate companion appeal challenges the underlying judgment.
  • Seeking intervention after preliminary settlement approval and class notice dissemination prejudices settling parties and weighs heavily against granting leave to intervene.

Why It Matters

This decision underscores the strict diligence required of class action practitioners and competing class counsel who suspect collusive settlement negotiations or reverse auctions. Parties cannot delay intervention while waiting for final terms or formal preliminary approval; once a party knows of a measurable risk to its interests, undue delay risks forfeiture on timeliness grounds.

The ruling also clarifies postjudgment intervention under amended section 387, affirming that the statutory shift to permitting intervention upon timely application allows postjudgment appeals to proceed where companion proceedings leave open an avenue to vacate the judgment.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top