California Case Summaries

McCaffrey v. Jen Milton Catering, LLC — Labor Commissioner appeal deadline is jurisdictional and cannot be excused by mistake or equitable relief

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
McCaffrey v. Jen Milton Catering, LLC
Court
1st District Court of Appeal
Judge
Rodríguez (Gavin Newsom, 2021); Tucher (Jerry Brown, 2018); Petrou
Date Decided
2026-11-18
Docket No.
A175195
Status
Unreported / Non-Citable
Topics
labor commissioner appeal, jurisdictional deadline, demurrer without leave to amend, equitable relief, self-represented litigant, wage and hour records

Background

Jesse McCaffrey, representing himself, filed a Labor Commissioner claim alleging his former employer, Jen Milton Catering, LLC, failed to provide access to or copies of payroll and personnel records under Labor Code sections 226, subdivision (f), and 1198.5, subdivision (k). The Labor Commissioner denied the claim in an order served by mail on September 18, 2023, making the superior-court appeal deadline October 3 after the five-day mail extension. The notice of appeal was file-stamped November 8.

McCaffrey told the trial court he attempted to file on October 3 but the papers were incomplete because of surprise, mistake, or excusable neglect, and he submitted an e-filing service email dated October 3 showing an appeal submitted pending clerk review. He also cited housing hardships and indigency, explaining he was unhoused, lacked regular mail access, retrieved the order on September 25, and later emailed the Labor Commissioner about his intent to appeal.

The trial court sustained Milton's demurrer without leave to amend because the appeal was untimely and denied McCaffrey's request for equitable relief from the deadline because he cited no legal authority showing the court could grant it.

The Court’s Holding

The Court of Appeal held the trial court properly sustained the demurrer because section 98.2's filing deadline is mandatory and jurisdictional. Even accepting McCaffrey's assertion that he filed on October 8 rather than November 8, the filing was late and the superior court had no jurisdiction to consider it; mistake, inadvertence, or excusable neglect cannot excuse the late notice of appeal.

The court also held the trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying leave to amend. McCaffrey identified no specific facts that could cure the jurisdictional defect, and his conclusory assertion did not establish a reasonable possibility of amendment.

A new argument in the reply brief that deficient documents submitted before the deadline are deemed timely filed was forfeited, and the court noted Dobarro v. Kim rejected the point in a section 98.2 appeal in any event.

Key Takeaways

  • Labor Code section 98.2 gives parties 10 days after service of a Labor Commissioner order to appeal to superior court, extended by five days for California mail service.
  • That deadline is mandatory and jurisdictional, so a late notice of appeal leaves the superior court without jurisdiction even where an e-filing service attempted a timely submission.
  • Mistake, inadvertence, excusable neglect, housing hardship, and indigency do not excuse a late section 98.2 appeal or support equitable tolling.
  • A plaintiff cannot obtain leave to amend to cure a jurisdictional filing defect without alleging specific facts showing a reasonable possibility the defect can be cured.
  • The judgment was affirmed, with each side bearing its own appellate costs in the interests of justice.

Why It Matters

This unpublished opinion reinforces that appeals from Labor Commissioner decisions are governed by a strict jurisdictional timetable and that electronic-filing difficulties do not create an equitable exception. Employers and workers should calendar the deadline from the service date and confirm actual court filing before it expires.

The decision also illustrates the limited room to amend after a demurrer based on a jurisdictional defect: speculation about filing mechanics will not substitute for specific curative allegations.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top