California Case Summaries

Karen Finck v. Dolgen California, LLC, et al. — Remand granted because defendants failed to prove fraudulent joinder of California manager

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Karen Finck v. Dolgen California, LLC, et al.
Court
U.S. District Court — Eastern District of California
Judge
Daniel J. Calabretta (Joe Biden, 2023)
Date Decided
2026-11-20
Docket No.
2:26-cv-02792
Status
Unreported
Topics
removal, remand, fraudulent joinder, diversity jurisdiction, California Labor Code, managing agent liability, attorneys’ fees

Background

Karen Finck, a former Dollar General employee and California resident, sued Dolgen California, LLC and Dollar General in Shasta County Superior Court alleging thirteen causes of action under the California Labor Code, the Fair Employment and Housing Act, and the Business and Professions Code. Defendants removed the case to the Eastern District of California based on diversity of citizenship, contending that California-resident defendant Ronnie Brice was fraudulently joined.

Finck moved to remand (ECF No. 3), arguing that Brice was not fraudulently joined and that the parties therefore were not completely diverse. She also challenged whether the amount in controversy exceeded $75,000 and requested attorneys' fees under 28 U.S.C. § 1447(c). The motion was fully briefed and submitted without oral argument under Local Rule 230(g).

Two of the thirteen causes of action named Brice alongside Dollar General: failure to reimburse business expenditures under California Labor Code § 2802 and failure to authorize and permit meal and rest periods under § 226.7. The complaint alleged Brice was a “Managing Agent” of Dollar General, and defendants did not dispute that California Labor Code § 558.1 permits individual managing agents to be held liable for violations of both statutes.

The Court’s Holding

Judge Daniel J. Calabretta applied the Ninth Circuit's stringent fraudulent-joinder standard, under which defendants must show there is “no possibility” that a state court would find the complaint states a cause of action against the non-diverse defendant. That burden is heavier than the Rule 12(b)(6) pleading standard, and a claim that might fail on a motion to dismiss is not necessarily fraudulently joined.

The court found defendants had not met that burden. They identified no procedural defense or immunity rendering the claims impossible, and the managing-agent allegation removed any statutory bar to Brice's potential liability under § 558.1. Although the court was skeptical the claims would survive Rule 12(b)(6), it held that the more permissive fraudulent-joinder test left open the possibility of colorable § 2802 and § 226.7 claims in state court. Any dispute over whether Brice was in fact a managing agent was resolved in favor of remand.

Because Brice's citizenship could not be disregarded, complete diversity was lacking and the court lacked jurisdiction. It therefore granted remand without reaching the amount-in-controversy question. The court denied Finck's request for § 1447(c) fees, finding defendants had an objectively reasonable basis for removal under Martin v. Franklin Capital Corp., and directed the Clerk to remand the case to Shasta County Superior Court and close the federal case.

Key Takeaways

  • Fraudulent joinder requires more than showing a claim would fail under Rule 12(b)(6); defendants must show there is no possibility of any state-court claim against the non-diverse defendant.
  • A complaint's allegation that a resident defendant was a “managing agent” can defeat fraudulent joinder where the cited Labor Code provision permits managing-agent liability and defendants identify no immunity or procedural bar.
  • Courts resolve factual disputes and ambiguity in favor of remand at the fraudulent-joinder stage, including disputes over the defendant's actual role.
  • Remand fees under § 1447(c) are unavailable where the removing defendants had an objectively reasonable basis for removal, even if removal ultimately fails.
  • Where diversity is absent, the court need not decide whether the amount in controversy exceeds $75,000.

Why It Matters

This order illustrates the practical difficulty of establishing fraudulent joinder in California employment cases involving individual managers. Even allegations the court doubted would survive a motion to dismiss were enough to require remand, because the jurisdictional inquiry is deliberately more permissive than merits screening.

The decision also reinforces that § 1447(c) fee awards remain exceptional: a removal position can be wrong yet still objectively reasonable, particularly where the fraudulent-joinder question turns on disputed allegations about a defendant's managerial role.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top