Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Sally Eagleman sued her employer, NaphCare, Inc., under California's Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), alleging disability discrimination, failure to accommodate, retaliation, and failure to engage in the interactive process. The district court granted summary judgment to NaphCare on all four claims, and Eagleman appealed.
The Ninth Circuit panel reviewed the summary judgment de novo, viewing the record and drawing all reasonable inferences in Eagleman's favor as the nonmoving party. The appeal was argued and submitted on October 29, 2026, in Pasadena, California.
Before her termination, Eagleman had exhausted FMLA-designated leave and provided two doctor's notes requesting additional leave through June 6, 2022. NaphCare internally discussed whether it was legally required to hold her position open and terminated her the day after her designated FMLA leave ended.
The Court’s Holding
The Ninth Circuit reversed summary judgment on all four claims. On disability discrimination, the panel found a genuine dispute of material fact regarding whether Eagleman could have performed essential job functions with the reasonable accommodation of additional leave, noting neither party anticipated her post-termination wrist surgery when NaphCare discharged her.
On failure to accommodate, the panel held that whether Eagleman's request for approximately one additional month of non-FMLA leave was finite or indefinite is a disputed question of material fact for a jury. Continued leave can itself constitute a reasonable accommodation under FEHA if likely to allow the employee to return to work, and NaphCare's generalized hardship assertions leave undue hardship in dispute.
The panel further held that the district court erroneously imported the disability discrimination 'qualified individual' requirement into Eagleman's retaliation and interactive-process claims. FEHA retaliation requires only protected activity, adverse action, and causation; requesting accommodation is protected activity whether granted or not. Similarly, failure to engage in the interactive process requires no qualified-individual showing, and Eagleman initiated the process by requesting leave.
Key Takeaways
- Continued finite leave can constitute a reasonable accommodation under FEHA if it is likely to be effective in enabling the employee to return to work.
- Whether an employee's leave extension request is finite or indefinite presents a triable question of material fact properly resolved by a jury.
- FEHA retaliation claims under California Government Code section 12940(h) are distinct from discrimination claims and do not require proof that the plaintiff is a qualified individual.
- An employer's duty to engage in a timely, good-faith interactive process under section 12940(n) does not require the employee to be a qualified individual once the employee initiates the process.
Why It Matters
This decision clarifies that FEHA retaliation and interactive-process claims do not import the 'qualified individual' element from disability discrimination, correcting a frequent district court error on summary judgment. It also confirms that holding a position open for finite medical leave may be required absent established undue hardship.
The panel left Eagleman's claim for punitive damages and her assertion of judicial estoppel for the district court to address on remand in the first instance.