Reported / Citable
Background
Douglas Smith taught high school chemistry and physical science for Burbank Unified School District. After the District required employees to be fully vaccinated against COVID-19 or obtain an authorized exemption for the 2021–2022 school year, Smith requested a religious exemption. The District granted his request, as it did every exemption request it received, but barred unvaccinated employees from physically entering campuses while the mandate remained effective. It offered Smith unpaid leave rather than his requested masking and PCR-testing arrangement. Smith used accrued paid time off before moving to unpaid leave, later began teaching at another school without a vaccine mandate, and resigned from the District effective June 2024 after declining to return.
Smith sued under the Fair Employment and Housing Act for religious discrimination, failure to prevent discrimination, and retaliation. The trial court granted the District's summary judgment motion. It found that Smith had established a prima facie case of religious discrimination, but that the District showed unpaid leave was the only reasonable accommodation that did not impose an undue burden. The court also found Smith's evidence insufficient to establish feasible alternatives or intentional discrimination. The Court of Appeal filed its original published opinion on October 7, 2026, affirming the judgment. On October 22, 2026, it modified that opinion, denied Smith's October 19 petition for rehearing and request for judicial notice, and expressly stated that there was no change in the judgment.
The Court’s Holding
The court independently reviewed summary judgment and rejected Smith's categorical argument that involuntary, indefinite unpaid leave can never be a reasonable religious accommodation. It reasoned that the leave eliminated the conflict between Smith's religious practice and the vaccination requirement, while preserving his ability to return to his former position when the mandate ended. Relying in part on Ansonia Board of Education v. Philbrook, the court also rejected his literal reading of the regulation addressing segregation from customers or the general public. The October 22 modification added that this regulatory sentence derives from the statutory provision concerning reasonable accommodations for religious dress and grooming.
The court further held that Smith did not produce evidence creating a triable issue over undue hardship. He did not dispute the Board's determination that vaccination was the most effective protection for employees and students, counter the District's declaration about classroom-coverage and supervision burdens, or controvert testimony about operational disruption during partial reopening. The District had treated exemption requests consistently: teachers with regular in-person contact received unpaid leave, while alternative accommodations went to nonteachers working in isolated offices. The October 22 order inserted the statutory definition of undue hardship, revised the costs provision so each party bears its own appellate costs, denied rehearing, and left the affirmance intact.
Key Takeaways
- Unpaid leave is not automatically an unreasonable religious accommodation under FEHA when it resolves the conflict with a job requirement and preserves an opportunity to return.
- A regulation's segregation language did not categorically disqualify unpaid leave in this case, particularly because that language derives from a provision addressing religious dress and grooming.
- An employee opposing summary judgment must supply evidence, rather than argument or speculation, to dispute an employer's showing of operational hardship and the feasibility of alternative accommodations.
- The District's consistent treatment of exempted teachers and its different accommodations for isolated nonteaching positions supported rejection of Smith's intentional-discrimination allegation.
- The October 22, 2026 order clarified the governing analysis and changed appellate costs, but denied rehearing and did not change the judgment affirming summary judgment.
Why It Matters
The decision explains how California's religious-accommodation rules applied to a school district's COVID-19 vaccine mandate, emphasizing the employee's evidentiary burden at summary judgment and the relationship between reasonable accommodation and undue hardship. The court grounded its analysis in Government Code section 12940, subdivision (l)(1), which prohibits religious discrimination unless the employer cannot reasonably accommodate the belief without undue hardship, and the October 22, 2026 order incorporated the undue-hardship factors from section 12926, subdivision (u). Its analysis is tied to the undisputed safety concerns, teaching duties, and operational evidence in this record rather than announcing that unpaid leave will always suffice.
The modification order is also substantively important: it added the statutory undue-hardship definition, clarified the limited origin of the regulation's segregation sentence, and replaced the District's costs award with each party bearing its own appellate costs. Those amendments accompanied denial of rehearing, not a reversal or alteration of the underlying affirmance.