California Case Summaries

Butler v. LAZ Parking California, LLC — Court of Appeal Reverses Denial of Motion to Compel Arbitration and Remands for Reconsideration of Severance Under Reduced Unconscionability Findings

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Butler v. LAZ Parking California, LLC
Court
4th District Court of Appeal, Division One
Judge
Rubin (Gavin Newsom, 2023); Do (Gavin Newsom, 2021); Castillo (Gavin Newsom, 2023)
Date Decided
2026-11-19
Docket No.
D085643
Status
Unreported / Non-Citable
Topics
arbitration agreements, unconscionability, mutuality, injunctive relief carveout, confidentiality agreements, class action waiver, PAGA waiver, contract severance

Background

Leonard Butler was hired as a hotel valet by LAZ Parking California, LLC in July 2022. During electronic onboarding, Butler signed several documents including an employee handbook acknowledgment, an agreement to arbitrate employment disputes, and a confidentiality and non-solicitation agreement. The arbitration agreement mandated binding arbitration for all employment disputes with an exception for injunctive relief, incorporated JAMS rules, and included a waiver of class, collective, and representative actions along with a severance clause. The separate confidentiality agreement provided that upon breach or threatened breach, the company was entitled to immediate injunctive relief without having to demonstrate actual damages.

Following the end of his employment, Butler filed a putative class action and later amended his complaint to allege representative claims under the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA) for California wage and hour violations. LAZ moved to compel individual arbitration, dismiss the class claims, and stay the non-individual PAGA claim. The trial court denied the motion, concluding that the agreement had low procedural unconscionability but high substantive unconscionability based on six provisions: lack of bilateral mutuality, an injunctive carveout favoring the employer, an unmerited damages waiver in the confidentiality agreement, a class waiver, a non-mutual attorney fee clause, and an invalid wholesale PAGA waiver. The trial court declined to sever any clauses, finding the contract permeated with an unlawful purpose, and LAZ appealed.

The Court’s Holding

The California Court of Appeal, Fourth Appellate District, Division One, reversed and remanded. Writing for the panel, Justice Rubin determined that the trial court erred in finding three of the challenged provisions substantively unconscionable. First, the court held that language stating the 'Employee agrees' to arbitrate all disputes created a mutual obligation binding both parties under established precedent. Second, the mutual carveout for provisional injunctive relief merely recited existing statutory rights under Code of Civil Procedure section 1281.8, subdivision (b) and was not unconscionable. Third, binding high court precedent establishes that class action waivers in employment arbitration agreements governed by the Federal Arbitration Act cannot be invalidated on state-law unconscionability grounds.

However, the appellate panel affirmed the trial court's substantive unconscionability findings as to the remaining three terms. The court concluded that the confidentiality agreement's enforcement clause improperly lowered the evidentiary standard for the employer to obtain extraordinary injunctive relief without showing actual damages or inadequate legal remedies. Additionally, LAZ conceded that the pre-dispute fee-shifting clause was unconscionable under governing California Supreme Court authority. Finally, the broad waiver of private attorney general claims was an invalid and substantively unconscionable wholesale PAGA waiver that was not rescued by a narrow savings clause in the handbook acknowledgment. Because only three rather than six provisions were unconscionable, the panel remanded for the trial court to exercise anew its discretion whether to sever the offending terms.

Key Takeaways

  • Unilateral phrasing such as 'Employee agrees' does not defeat contractual mutuality where the agreement covers all disputes arising out of the employment relationship and is executed by both parties.
  • Carveouts allowing either party to seek provisional injunctive relief in court merely confirm statutory remedies under California Code of Civil Procedure section 1281.8 and do not render an arbitration clause unconscionable.
  • Confidentiality provisions that contractually entitle an employer to immediate injunctive relief without proving irreparable harm or inadequate damages grant an unfair advantage and are substantively unconscionable.
  • Sweeping waivers of representative PAGA claims remain substantively unconscionable under California law and cannot be salvaged by narrow, separate handbook savings clauses.
  • When an appellate court invalidates some but not all unconscionability findings underpinning a trial court's refusal to sever, the trial court must reconsider the severance question anew.

Why It Matters

The decision clarifies the boundaries of substantive unconscionability in California employment onboarding agreements, emphasizing that mutual all-dispute commitments and statutory provisional-remedy carveouts withstand challenge even in adhesive employment settings.

By narrowing the number of unconscionable terms from six to three and remanding for fresh evaluation under Civil Code section 1670.5, the opinion underscores that trial courts must base severance permeation determinations on legally sound unconscionability findings rather than permissible standard terms.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top