Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Plaintiff Brandon Williams worked from July 2024 to December 2025 as a cafe attendant for ISS Facility Services, Inc. and Guckenheimer Enterprises, Inc. at Atlassian's San Francisco office. Williams alleged persistent discrimination, harassment, and retaliation throughout his employment. In May 2025, Williams complained to human resources employee Karen Hong that Spanish-speaking coworkers repeatedly referenced his name. Shortly after, supervisor Norma Bernabe barred him from playing kitchen music and disciplined him for using the phrase 'bitch, I love you,' which Williams explained was an affectionate colloquialism common in the LGBTQ+ community.
Workplace tensions escalated after Williams suffered a work-related back injury in June 2025. Regional director Dan Urban repeatedly told Williams to 'act like a man' and handle problems like a grown man, allegedly calling Williams dramatic because of his sex, sexual orientation, and gender expression. After a kitchen dispute and a second back injury, Hong and Urban confronted Williams in November 2025 over recording policies. When Williams asked to leave because he felt unwell, Hong placed both hands on his arm without consent and over his objection as a gay man. Following an immediate suspension, Williams constructively resigned in December 2025.
Williams sued, asserting twenty-one causes of action, including discrimination and hostile work environment claims under Title VII and California's Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA). Defendants moved to compel arbitration under the Federal Arbitration Act. Williams opposed the motion, contending defendants failed to establish mutual assent and that any agreement was unenforceable under the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act of 2021 (EFAA).
The Court’s Holding
United States District Judge Haywood S. Gilliam, Jr. denied the motion to compel arbitration, holding that Williams properly invoked the EFAA to render the arbitration agreement unenforceable. Under 9 U.S.C. § 402(a), at the election of a person alleging conduct constituting a sexual harassment dispute, no predispute arbitration agreement is valid or enforceable in a case relating to that dispute. Pursuant to 9 U.S.C. § 402(b), the court must resolve statutory applicability, and because the EFAA was dispositive, the court declined to reach Williams's assent arguments.
Defendants conceded that Title VII and FEHA claims can constitute sexual harassment disputes under the EFAA, but argued Williams failed to plausibly allege conduct related to his sex or sexual orientation. The district court rejected that contention under the Ninth Circuit's recent decision in Holland-Thielen v. SpaceX. Holland-Thielen held that sexual harassment allegations need not satisfy federal plausibility pleading standards before the EFAA applies. Instead, a complaint sufficiently invokes the statute if it asserts that certain conduct amounted to sexual harassment under applicable law and asserts at least one claim premised on that conduct.
Because Williams asserted Title VII and FEHA claims alleging harassment based on sex, sexual orientation, and gender expression—including allegations that Urban told him to 'act like a man'—he successfully invoked the EFAA. Under Holland-Thielen, establishing a qualifying dispute exempts the plaintiff's entire case from arbitration, even where companion causes of action do not involve sexual harassment. The court denied the motion to compel without prejudice to defendants renewing their arbitration request if they successfully dismiss the harassment claims on a Rule 12(b)(6) motion.
Key Takeaways
- Under Holland-Thielen v. SpaceX, sexual harassment allegations need not satisfy Rule 12(b)(6) plausibility pleading standards before a plaintiff can invoke the EFAA to defeat arbitration.
- A complaint properly triggers the EFAA whenever it asserts that challenged conduct constituted sexual harassment under applicable substantive law and includes at least one claim premised on that conduct.
- Pleading a single qualifying sexual harassment claim invalidates predispute arbitration agreements as to the entire action, allowing all non-harassment companion claims to remain in federal court.
- Employers defending against EFAA-exempted complaints must obtain formal dismissal of qualifying harassment claims on the merits before renewing any motion to compel arbitration of remaining claims.
Why It Matters
This decision underscores the direct operational effect of the Ninth Circuit's Holland-Thielen precedent in preventing employers from subjecting EFAA disputes to preliminary merits screening at the motion to compel stage. By decoupling statutory arbitration exemption from Rule 12(b)(6) dismissal standards, courts ensure immediate access to a judicial forum for harassment claims.
Additionally, the ruling highlights the circuit's case-wide preclusion rule, which bars piecemeal arbitration of joined commercial or wage claims once harassment is asserted. Defendants must formally prevail on a motion to dismiss before arbitration rights can be revived.