California Case Summaries

Baptiste v. State of Cal. — Appellate modification order changes judgment and denies rehearing in wage-and-pleadings appeal

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Baptiste v. State of California et al.
Court
4th District Court of Appeal, Division Three
Judge
Scott (Gavin Newsom, 2025); Moore (Gray Davis, 2000); Gooding (Gavin Newsom, 2023)
Date Decided
2026-11-18
Docket No.
G065245M
Status
Unreported / Non-Citable
Topics
appellate modification, rehearing denial, change in judgment, pleading defects, Government Claims Act, motions to strike, leave to amend, judgment on the pleadings

Background

Jetta J. Baptiste, appearing in propria persona, appealed a Superior Court of Orange County judgment of dismissal entered after Judge Bradley S. Erdosi granted motions to strike her fifth amended complaint in its entirety. Her underlying suit alleged she was not paid for providing in-home health care during the COVID-19 pandemic, and the appeal encompassed intermediate rulings on earlier complaints as well as the final judgment.

The Court of Appeal's October 22, 2026 opinion affirmed the judgment as to ten defendants but reversed as to eleven others. It remanded claims against Debra Baetz, Stephanie Hooker, Loan English, and Aaron Hogue for adjudication of sixteen causes of action, and remanded the fifth amended complaint as to seven defendants who had never challenged the pleading. The opinion was certified not for publication.

After that decision, the court issued this order modifying the opinion and ruling on a petition for rehearing. The modification was narrow and textual: it relocated the party name "County of Orange" from one paragraph on page 19 of the opinion to another paragraph on the same page.

The Court’s Holding

The court ordered two page-19 edits: insert "County of Orange" after "(IHSS)" in the paragraph beginning "Baptiste," and delete "County of Orange" from the paragraph beginning "Defendants." The court expressly stated, "This modification changes the judgment."

The petition for rehearing was denied. The order was signed by Justice Scott, with Acting Presiding Justice Moore and Justice Gooding concurring, matching the panel that issued the underlying opinion.

Key Takeaways

  • A modification order can change the judgment even when the textual edit is limited to relocating a party name between paragraphs of the opinion.
  • The court expressly acknowledged that its modification changed the judgment, signaling that the cost-allocation and disposition treatment of County of Orange was affected by the edit.
  • Denial of rehearing left the modified opinion's core rulings intact: affirmance for ten defendants, reversal for eleven, and remand for adjudication of specified causes of action.
  • The opinion and modification remain unpublished and subject to California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a).

Why It Matters

This order illustrates how a post-opinion modification can have judgment-level consequences without altering the legal analysis. By expressly labeling the change as one to the judgment, the court preserved clarity about which defendants bear costs and which claims proceed on remand.

For practitioners, the order underscores the importance of monitoring modification and rehearing rulings after an appellate decision issues, because even clerical-looking edits can affect the operative judgment and the parties' rights.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top