California Case Summaries

Strike 3 Holdings, LLC v. John Doe Subscriber Assigned IP 98.51.15.206 — Third-Party Subpoena to Identify Internet Subscriber Granted with Protective Procedural Safeguards

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Strike 3 Holdings, LLC v. John Doe Subscriber Assigned IP 98.51.15.206
Court
U.S. District Court — Eastern District of California
Judge
Carolyn K. Delaney (U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California, 2011)
Date Decided
2026-11-20
Docket No.
2:26-cv-03750
Status
Unreported
Topics
expedited discovery, Rule 26(d), third-party subpoena, internet service provider, anonymous subscriber privacy, copyright infringement

Background

Plaintiff Strike 3 Holdings, LLC sued an anonymous subscriber assigned IP address 98.51.15.206 for copyright infringement, alleging the unauthorized download and distribution of adult films via BitTorrent. Because Strike 3 could identify the alleged infringer solely by IP address, it filed an ex parte application under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(d) seeking expedited discovery to serve a third-party subpoena on the subscriber's internet service provider prior to a Rule 26(f) conference.

Strike 3 asserted that without an ISP subpoena to obtain the subscriber's true name and address, it could not serve process or vindicate its copyrights. In the Ninth Circuit, courts evaluate whether good cause justifies early discovery by balancing the need for expedited disclosure against potential prejudice to the responding party, weighing the plaintiff's prima facie showing against subscriber privacy interests.

The Court’s Holding

United States Magistrate Judge Carolyn K. Delaney granted the ex parte application on the terms of the order, allowing Strike 3 to subpoena the internet service provider solely for the subscriber's true name and address. Evaluating the Arista Records factors, the court found the first four factors weighed in Strike 3's favor because it stated a prima facie claim, sought only identifying information, lacked alternative means, and needed the data to proceed. However, the court held that the fifth factor—the subscriber's expectation of privacy—weighed against granting the request without safeguards, citing the tenuous connection between account holders and actual downloaders and the risk of reputational coercion in adult film suits.

To safeguard privacy, the court ordered Strike 3 to serve a copy of the order on the identified individual within ten days of obtaining their identity, unless dismissed earlier. The court barred formal service of process absent further order and cautioned Strike 3 not to reveal the defendant's identity in or out of court without permission. The magistrate judge invited the parties to a voluntary informal conference to coordinate motions to quash or service procedures without waiving service or appearing, required a 60-day status report continuing to identify defendant as John or Jane Doe, and noted that declining to attend will lead to an order substituting the defendant by name for ordinary service.

Key Takeaways

  • Plaintiffs in BitTorrent copyright actions may establish good cause for pre-conference subpoenas, but courts closely scrutinize the gap between an IP subscriber and the actual infringer.
  • To mitigate coercive settlement pressure in adult film suits, courts may caution against disclosing subscriber identities and bar formal service without prior authorization.
  • Courts may offer voluntary informal conferences allowing subscribers to schedule motions to quash or address service without waiving formal service or entering an appearance.
  • An identified subscriber's decision not to attend an informal conference leads to an order substituting them by name, permitting ordinary service of process and litigation.

Why It Matters

This decision illustrates the Eastern District of California's balanced approach to BitTorrent copyright litigation, reconciling a copyright holder's need to unmask infringers with safeguards against mistaken identity and reputational embarrassment. By halting immediate service, restricting out-of-court disclosure, and providing a voluntary pre-service conference, the court protects accused subscribers while establishing a clear procedural pathway to formal litigation if they decline to participate.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top