Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Strike 3 Holdings sued an anonymous John Doe identified only by IP address 98.238.135.244, alleging the subscriber used BitTorrent to download and distribute copyrighted adult films. Because the defendant could not be named or served, Strike 3 sought ex parte leave to subpoena the internet service provider before the Rule 26(f) conference.
The court applied the Ninth Circuit's good-cause standard for early discovery and the five Arista factors: prima facie showing, request specificity, lack of alternative means, need for the information, and the defendant's privacy expectation. The first four factors favored discovery, but the privacy factor required additional safeguards rather than supporting the unqualified relief requested.
Relying on In re BitTorrent Adult Film Copyright Infringement Cases and Manny Film, the court emphasized that an IP subscriber is not necessarily the infringer, especially where routers and shared connections are common. It also recognized the particular embarrassment and settlement pressure created by wrongly accusing someone of downloading pornography.
The Court’s Holding
The court granted the ex parte application and permitted limited expedited discovery: the subpoena may seek only the true name and address of the person or entity to whom the subject IP address is assigned. Strike 3 must serve a copy of the order on the identified person or entity within ten days after learning the identity, unless the action is dismissed before that period expires.
No formal service of process may occur without further court order. The parties are invited to a voluntary informal conference to address a motion-to-quash schedule and service or waiver procedures, and Strike 3 must file a status report within 60 days while continuing to identify the defendant as John or Jane Doe.
Strike 3 is cautioned not to reveal the defendant's identity in or out of court until the court gives permission. If the identified owner declines the informal conference, that decision will lead to an order substituting the identified defendant by name, permitting ordinary service of process, and commencement of the litigation. Nothing in the order precludes settlement without court participation before any informal conference or formal service.
Key Takeaways
- Expedited discovery to identify a Doe defendant requires good cause, and courts may tailor the subpoena to the minimum information needed.
- An IP-address subscriber is not automatically the BitTorrent infringer; shared routers and devices weaken that inference and require additional proof of identity as the infringer.
- Where adult-content allegations create acute reputational risk, courts can require notice to the subscriber, preserve an opportunity to quash, and prohibit public naming until further leave or substitution applies.
- If the identified subscriber decides not to attend the informal conference, the court will enter an order substituting the defendant by name, permitting ordinary service of process and commencement of litigation.
Why It Matters
The order shows how copyright plaintiffs can obtain early identifying discovery while courts build procedural protections against mistaken-identity and privacy harms in adult-film BitTorrent cases.
It also preserves the subscriber's ability to challenge the subpoena before being named or served, while providing a defined path to substitution and ordinary service if the identified owner declines the informal conference.