California Case Summaries

Strike 3 Holdings, LLC v. John Doe Subscriber Assigned IP 76.20.77.189 — Magistrate judge grants early ISP subpoena but adds privacy safeguards for anonymous BitTorrent defendant

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Strike 3 Holdings, LLC v. John Doe Subscriber Assigned IP 76.20.77.189
Court
U.S. District Court — Eastern District of California
Judge
Carolyn K. Delaney (U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California, 2011)
Date Decided
2026-11-20
Docket No.
2:26-cv-03748
Status
Unreported
Topics
expedited discovery, anonymous BitTorrent defendant, ISP subpoena, privacy safeguards, copyright infringement, Rule 26(d), motion to quash, informal conference

Background

Strike 3 Holdings filed a copyright infringement action alleging that an anonymous defendant identified only by IP address 76.20.77.189 used the BitTorrent protocol to download and distribute its adult films. (ECF No. 1.) Because Strike 3 could identify the defendant only by that IP address, it filed an ex parte application for leave to serve a third-party subpoena on the defendant's internet service provider prior to a Rule 26(f) conference, asserting it could not otherwise identify or serve the defendant. (ECF No. 3-1.)

United States Magistrate Judge Carolyn K. Delaney evaluated the request under the Ninth Circuit's good-cause standard for expedited discovery and the Second Circuit's five-factor Arista Records framework, which weighs the prima facie claim, the specificity of the discovery, the absence of alternative means, the need for the information, and the defendant's expectation of privacy. The magistrate judge found the first four factors favored Strike 3 but concluded that the privacy factor counseled against unconditioned discovery.

Emphasizing constitutional privacy protections and decisions such as In re BitTorrent Adult Film Copyright Infringement Cases and Manny Film LLC v. Doe, the magistrate judge observed that an IP subscriber is often not the individual who downloaded a file over a shared router. Given that the allegations involved adult films, the magistrate judge highlighted the acute risk of embarrassment, reputational damage, and coerced settlements for mistakenly identified subscribers.

The Court’s Holding

The magistrate judge granted Strike 3's ex parte application on the specific terms set forth in the order. Strike 3 was permitted to serve a subpoena on the ISP seeking solely the true name and address of the subscriber assigned to the IP address, and was directed to serve a copy of the order on that individual within ten days of obtaining their identity, unless the action is dismissed earlier.

The order prohibited formal service of process absent further court order. The magistrate judge invited Strike 3 and the potential defendant to participate in a voluntary informal conference via telephone or Zoom to establish procedures for service or waiver and set a schedule for any motion to quash, confirming that attendance would not waive service or constitute a litigation appearance.

Strike 3 was ordered to file a status report within 60 days addressing service, conference attendance, and format preferences, while continuing to identify the defendant as John or Jane Doe. Strike 3 is barred from disclosing the defendant's identity in or out of court without authorization. If the identified subscriber declines the informal conference, the court will order substitution by name and permit ordinary service. The order does not preclude private settlement.

Key Takeaways

  • An IP address identifies only an internet account or router location, not necessarily the individual who engaged in copyright infringement.
  • Expedited pre-conference discovery under Rule 26(d) is strictly limited to discovering the subscriber's true name and address from the ISP.
  • The identified subscriber must receive a copy of the court's order within ten days and has an opportunity to attend an informal conference to schedule a motion to quash before formal service.
  • The plaintiff is prohibited from revealing the subscriber's identity in or out of court without judicial permission, minimizing reputational exposure and settlement coercion.
  • Formal service of process is barred until the court authorizes it, but a subscriber's refusal to attend an informal conference will result in substitution by name and regular service.

Why It Matters

The ruling exemplifies the rigorous procedural protections federal magistrate judges apply to balance copyright enforcement against subscriber privacy in adult-film BitTorrent litigation.

By conditioning early ISP subpoenas on delayed service, protective notice, a pre-service quash window, and strict anonymity, the court prevents abusive settlement tactics while preserving a viable pathway for legitimate infringement claims.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top