Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Strike 3 Holdings sued a John Doe identified only by an IP address, alleging the defendant used BitTorrent to download and distribute copyrighted adult films. Because the defendant could not be named or served, Strike 3 sought an ex parte order allowing a third-party subpoena to the internet service provider before the Rule 26(f) conference.
The court applied the Ninth Circuit's good-cause standard for early discovery and the five-factor framework from Arista Records, LLC v. Doe 3: the concreteness of the prima facie claim, specificity of the requests, lack of alternative means, need for the information, and the defendant's privacy expectation.
The first four factors favored discovery because Strike 3 supplied download records, sought only the subscriber's true name and address, had no other way to identify the defendant, and could not proceed without that identity. The privacy factor, however, required safeguards given the sensitive nature of the accused films and the weak inference that the account subscriber is the infringer.
The Court’s Holding
The court granted the ex parte application on the order's terms, allowing only a subpoena seeking the true name and address assigned to the subject IP address. It barred formal service absent further order and required Strike 3 to serve the order on the identified person within ten days after obtaining the actual identity, unless the action is dismissed before that ten-day period expires.
The order invited both sides to a voluntary informal conference to schedule any motion to quash and address service or waiver, required a 60-day status report continuing to use a Doe designation, and cautioned Strike 3 not to reveal the defendant's identity without court permission. The court emphasized that identifying the subscriber would likely require additional proof of infringement.
Key Takeaways
- Early discovery to identify a Doe defendant requires good cause, and courts may use the Arista factors even when no motion to quash is pending.
- An IP address identifies a connection location, not necessarily the person who committed the alleged download, so subscriber identity alone may not establish infringement.
- Courts can condition ISP subpoenas in adult-film BitTorrent cases with narrow information limits, delayed service, voluntary conferences, and confidentiality protections to reduce mistaken-identity and settlement-pressure risks.
- Failure to engage in the informal process can lead to substitution of the named defendant and ordinary service, while settlement remains possible without court involvement.
Why It Matters
The order shows how courts balance copyright plaintiffs' need to identify anonymous online infringers against constitutional privacy interests and the particular reputational harm of adult-content allegations.
By combining a granted subpoena with staged service, quash opportunities, and identity nondisclosure, the court created a procedural template for managing early discovery without deciding the merits of infringement.