Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Ricky Norman Rollins, Jr. appealed in Nos. 25-3701 and 25-3702 from the Northern District of California (Judge William Alsup). The caption lists district court numbers 3:05-cr-00167-WHA-6 and 3:24-cr-00064-WHA-1. The memorandum discusses only one history: on February 11, 2025, Rollins pleaded guilty to one count of being a felon in possession of a firearm under 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1). His conditional plea preserved the right to appeal the denial of his motion to suppress the firearm. The memorandum does not explain how the other appeal relates to this issue.
Rollins argued that Officer Ericka Viola, who found the firearm, violated the Fourth Amendment in three ways. He said she lacked sufficient reason to believe he was armed and presently dangerous, that she exceeded a permissible frisk by manipulating his groin area, and that she conducted a cross-gender frisk.
The panel decided the case without oral argument on submission on October 21, 2026. It was composed of Circuit Judges Callahan and Lee and District Judge Ezra of the District of Hawaii, sitting by designation. The court reviewed the suppression denial and reasonable-suspicion determinations de novo and the district court's factual findings for clear error, deferring to inferences drawn by the district court and the officers on the scene.
The Court’s Holding
The Ninth Circuit affirmed. On reasonable suspicion, it applied the totality of the circumstances and rejected any divide-and-conquer analysis. It relied on three facts known to Officer Viola. She was executing a warrant to search another man and his apartment, where Rollins was an overnight guest, for weapons in an attempted murder investigation. Rollins was on probation or supervised release. And he sat on a couch between two people, one of whom was unrestrained, covered by a blanket, and permitted to move around the living room. Together these facts supported a reasonable belief that Rollins was armed and presently dangerous.
On scope, the court held that the frisk was reasonably designed to discover weapons and limited to what was minimally necessary to learn whether Rollins was armed and to disarm him. Officer Viola was searching for weapons and had not ruled out a weapon in the groin area when she manipulated it. The court cited United States v. Mattarolo, which found a precautionary squeeze of an object that could be a knife justified for officer safety.
On the cross-gender challenge, the court noted that Byrd v. Maricopa County Sheriff's Department found cross-gender strip searches of inmates unreasonable absent an emergency. Under Grummett v. Rushen, however, cross-gender pat-downs of the groin area are not unreasonable when done professionally and with respect. Officer Viola patted down the outside of Rollins's clothes and then reached into his pants to retrieve what she believed was a firearm. The court called this far less invasive than the searches in Byrd. It added that Rollins began to resist by clenching his legs and slipping free from his flex cuffs, creating an emergency that justified securing the firearm.
Key Takeaways
- Reasonable suspicion that a person is armed is assessed on the totality of the circumstances, including officers' training and experience and the cumulative information available to them.
- Here, a weapons-search warrant tied to an attempted murder investigation, the suspect's supervised status, and an unrestrained person nearby together supported a frisk of a guest in the apartment.
- Manipulating the groin area during a frisk stayed within Terry's scope where the officer had not ruled out a weapon there.
- The searching officer's gender did not by itself make a professional pat-down unreasonable, particularly because the search was far less invasive than the strip searches in Byrd.
- A suspect's resistance during a frisk, such as clenching his legs and slipping free from flex cuffs, can create an emergency that justifies steps needed to secure a suspected firearm.
Why It Matters
This unpublished memorandum is not precedent except as provided by Ninth Circuit Rule 36-3. It shows the panel treating Terry-frisk challenges as fact-specific, turning on what the officer knew and on the need to find and secure weapons rather than on isolated techniques.
It also shows the panel declining to extend Byrd's cross-gender strip-search holding to a pat-down and retrieval of a suspected firearm, and instead applying Grummett. The memorandum says nothing further about the other appeal listed in the caption.