Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
A jury convicted Edwin Montoya of rape and penetration of the genital opening by a foreign object, and the trial court sentenced him to six years in state prison. During the investigation, the complaining witness conducted pretext phone calls and text messages under police instruction, during which she feigned pregnancy and asked why he had not stopped when told no; Montoya claimed he thought she had said not to stop.
During deliberations on April 7, 2025, the jury deadlocked on both counts. Montoya subsequently moved for a new trial, submitting a declaration from Juror No. 9 stating that another juror (Juror No. 7) reported conducting independent research on entrapment and stated that rapists repeat their crimes and holdout jurors voting not guilty would bear responsibility if he raped again. The trial court admitted only the portion regarding independent research, determined it was misconduct but nonprejudicial, and denied the motion.
The Court’s Holding
The California Third District Court of Appeal affirmed the judgment. Assuming without deciding that the juror's statement concerning recidivism was admissible and constituted juror misconduct giving rise to a presumption of prejudice, the court concluded upon the whole record that there was no substantial likelihood any juror was improperly influenced to Montoya's detriment.
The court reasoned that the comment was objectively unpersuasive because the jury took a vote shortly after the comment was made and remained deadlocked, with all twelve jurors informing the trial court that further deliberations would not produce a verdict. The deadlock was broken on April 8 only after counsel for both sides presented supplemental arguments at the jury's request, demonstrating that counsel's additional arguments, rather than the juror's remark, led to the verdict.
Key Takeaways
- Even when assuming juror statements constitute misconduct, the presumption of prejudice is rebutted where the record shows no substantial likelihood of improper influence.
- A challenged comment during deliberations does not establish prejudice when jurors hold a subsequent vote and remain deadlocked on all counts immediately following the remark.
- Verdicts reached after court-permitted supplemental arguments can substantiate that the impasse was broken by counsel's arguments rather than prior intra-jury comments.
Why It Matters
This decision illustrates the application of California's three-step juror misconduct framework, confirming that intermediate deadlocks and requested supplemental arguments serve as concrete record evidence rebutting presumed prejudice from inappropriate juror remarks during deliberations.