Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Following a parking space dispute in May 2024, Seendee Maldonado Lopez escalated a verbal encounter into an unprovoked physical assault. After punching the victim in the eye, Lopez retrieved a knife from her purse while two companions beat the victim on the ground, and she repeatedly stabbed him in the torso. The victim suffered critical, permanent injuries, including the loss of a kidney and part of his intestines, requiring prolonged hospitalization, a coma, and the permanent use of a colostomy bag.
Charged with attempted first-degree murder with great bodily injury and deadly weapon allegations, Lopez moved for pretrial mental health diversion under Penal Code section 1001.36. She submitted a forensic psychological evaluation diagnosing her with depressive disorder, posttraumatic stress disorder, and severe substance use disorders stemming from chronic trauma. Although the expert opined that Lopez's conditions responded well to treatment and that she posed no unreasonable risk to public safety due to her lack of prior criminal history, the trial court denied diversion, concluding that the extreme gravity and violence of the offense demonstrated an unreasonable risk of committing a super strike under Penal Code section 1170.18.
The Court’s Holding
The California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, Division Seven, affirmed the judgment of conviction entered after Lopez pleaded no contest to attempted second-degree murder. The appellate court held that the trial court acted well within its discretion in finding Lopez unsuitable for diversion based on public safety concerns.
The court rejected Lopez's contention that her lack of prior criminal history and positive response to custody treatment rendered the dangerousness finding unsupported. Under Penal Code section 1001.36, subdivision (c)(4), a trial court is entitled to consider the charged offense itself, and nothing precludes relying primarily or entirely on the egregious circumstances of the offense. Furthermore, the trial court was not required to adopt the defense psychologist's opinion regarding public safety, as the finder of fact retains exclusive authority to determine the weight and credibility of expert testimony.
Key Takeaways
- A trial court may rely primarily or entirely on the egregious circumstances of the charged offense to find that a defendant poses an unreasonable risk to public safety under Penal Code section 1001.36.
- A lack of prior criminal convictions does not preclude a finding of dangerousness when the current offense involves extreme, unprovoked violence and severe bodily injury.
- Trial courts are not bound by a qualified mental health expert's conclusion that a defendant would not pose an unreasonable risk of danger if treated in the community.
- The statutory standard of an unreasonable risk of danger under section 1170.18 requires assessing the risk of committing a super strike violent felony, which includes attempted murder.
Why It Matters
This decision reinforces established California precedent holding that the statutory suitability determination for mental health diversion leaves broad discretion to trial judges. Even where a defendant establishes statutory eligibility, an expert diagnosis, and a lack of prior criminal history, the severe factual circumstances of an unprovoked violent crime can independently sustain a finding of public danger.
The opinion also notes the legislative amendment to Penal Code section 1001.36 effective January 1, 2027, which replaces the 'unreasonable risk of danger to public safety' standard tied to section 1170.18 super strikes with a 'substantial and undue risk to the physical safety of another person' standard.