Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
In 1994, two armed men entered a residence under the guise of buying marijuana, drew handguns, and initiated a robbery. Steve Flowers and an accomplice waited outside in a vehicle as backup in case the transaction went wrong. Approximately ten minutes later, Flowers entered the home when summoned. Over the course of thirty to sixty minutes, four occupants were tied face down, beaten, and robbed. One victim was shot and repeatedly stabbed, and a bystander who interrupted the robbery was fatally shot in the back.
Flowers admitted entering the residence, seeing bound victims, searching for string to tie up victims, and looking for items to steal. After the fatal shooting, Flowers fled with the group, discussed the stolen marijuana, and left California without rendering aid. In 1997, a jury convicted Flowers of first-degree murder, torture, and robbery, with a robbery-murder special circumstance. In 2019, Flowers petitioned for resentencing under Penal Code section 1172.6. Following an evidentiary hearing, the trial court denied the petition.
The Court’s Holding
The California Court of Appeal affirmed the denial of Flowers's petition. The court rejected Flowers's argument for independent review based on a cold record, confirming that substantial evidence governs review of factual findings following a section 1172.6 evidentiary hearing. Applying the Banks factors, the court held substantial evidence supported the finding that Flowers was a major participant. Although Flowers was not the shooter and did not supply weapons, he agreed to act as backup, entered during an active robbery, searched for restraint materials, ransacked the house, and fled without aiding bound victims.
Applying the Clark factors, the court held substantial evidence supported the finding that Flowers acted with reckless indifference to human life. Flowers remained present for most of a prolonged, violent home-invasion robbery where confederates beat, stabbed, and shot victims. Despite observing this escalating lethal violence, Flowers failed to act as a restraining influence, facilitated the restraint of the victims, and fled immediately after the fatal shooting leaving injured victims bound and unable to summon aid.
Key Takeaways
- Appellate courts review a trial court's factual findings following a Penal Code section 1172.6 evidentiary hearing for substantial evidence, even when decided on a cold documentary record.
- Acting as operational backup, entering an ongoing armed robbery, and searching for materials to tie up victims support a finding of major participation under the Banks factors.
- Prolonged presence during escalating violence without attempting to restrain armed confederates, followed by immediate flight without rendering aid to bound victims, demonstrates reckless indifference to human life under Clark.
- A defendant's youth at the time of the offense is a relevant factor along the culpability spectrum, but youth alone is not dispositive and does not overcome substantial evidence of major participation and reckless indifference.
Why It Matters
This decision reinforces California appellate consensus declining to extend independent review under People v. Vivar to Penal Code section 1172.6 hearings. It also demonstrates that a non-shooter who serves as backup and assists in victim restraint during a prolonged armed robbery exhibits sufficient culpability under Banks and Clark to sustain felony-murder liability.