Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
In December 2018, defendant Jorge Alberto Farias and codefendant Michael James Bloom attacked fellow inmate G.R. at Salinas Valley State Prison. G.R. suffered 28 stab wounds and serious internal injuries; the weapon was never recovered, but Farias had cuts and blood on his hands and later flushed his toilet.
A 2024 jury convicted Farias of attempted premeditated murder and assault with a deadly weapon by a prisoner, finding true great-bodily-injury enhancements. The court found true two strike priors and two prior serious felony convictions, and sentenced Farias to 25 years to life plus eight years in enhancements.
Farias argued the trial court should have dismissed enhancements under Penal Code section 1385(c)(2), citing mental illness and the remoteness of his priors, and alternatively that counsel was ineffective for not raising two additional statutory mitigating circumstances.
The Court’s Holding
The court held the trial court did not abuse its discretion. The record did not substantially establish the DSM disorder global developmental delay or connect any impairment to the offense, and the court could reasonably find countervailing considerations—continued violence, including this attack—outweighed the age of the prior convictions.
Farias forfeited appellate claims based on the multiple-enhancement and over-20-year mitigating circumstances by not raising them below. Counsel was not ineffective: the over-20-year circumstance did not apply as a matter of law because the Three Strikes terms already exceeded 20 years without the enhancements, and Farias showed no prejudice from omitting the multiple-enhancement argument.
The court affirmed the judgment and, on its own, directed the trial court to amend the abstract of judgment to show sentencing under the Three Strikes law and send a certified copy to corrections.
Key Takeaways
- Section 1385(c)(2) requires great weight for qualifying mitigation, but countervailing evidence can justify retaining an enhancement absent abuse of discretion.
- Generalized evidence of developmental disability did not establish the DSM-5-TR diagnosis of global developmental delay or a substantial connection to the offense.
- An enhancement does not trigger the over-20-year mitigating circumstance unless the enhancement itself causes a sentence exceeding 20 years.
- Claims based on mitigating circumstances not raised at sentencing may be forfeited, and counsel is not ineffective for omitting meritless arguments.
- Appellate courts may correct an unraised clerical sentencing-record error while affirming the judgment.
Why It Matters
This unpublished decision applies Walker and Torres to Senate Bill No. 81 enhancement-dismissal standards, emphasizing the evidentiary link required for mental-illness mitigation and the causal reading of the over-20-year factor.
It also illustrates correction of a Three Strikes abstract-of-judgment omission without disturbing the substantive judgment.