Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
A jury convicted Christopher Ryder Lang of two counts of second degree commercial burglary arising from a March 27, 2022 incident where he and an accomplice used a stolen dump truck to ram storefronts in Richmond and El Sobrante to steal ATMs. After Lang fled on foot from the second location, deputies recovered a jacket containing his DNA, identifying him as the perpetrator.
On January 14, 2025, the jury convicted Lang on both counts. At a bifurcated trial the next day, the jury found true that the crimes involved planning, sophistication, or professionalism, but deadlocked on an allegation of damage of great monetary value. The trial court declared a mistrial on that allegation, which the prosecution then dismissed. The court sentenced Lang to an upper term of three years on count one and a concurrent two years on count two as a split sentence—one year in jail and two years on mandatory supervision—plus $31,300 in restitution.
The upper term rested on four aggravating factors, but only planning and sophistication was found true by the jury. The parties agreed that under People v. Wiley (2025) 17 Cal.5th 1069, the trial court erred by relying on the other three factors without jury findings or stipulations. In his reply brief, Lang conceded his prior probation performance was unsatisfactory, and he raised no challenge to the concurrent-sentencing factor.
The Court’s Holding
Applying Chapman review as directed by Wiley, the Court of Appeal held the sentencing error harmless beyond a reasonable doubt because no rational juror could have found against the aggravating factors. Lang's certified criminal record established four prior felony convictions escalating from accessory after the fact and failure to appear to firearm possession and receiving a stolen vehicle, culminating in destructive commercial burglaries that caused immense property damage.
The court also held unsatisfactory probation performance was proved beyond a reasonable doubt by undisputed records showing multiple probation violations and new offenses committed during supervision. Finally, because Lang failed to brief or challenge the court's consideration of concurrent sentencing on count two, the court declined to address that factor and affirmed the judgment.
Key Takeaways
- Under People v. Wiley, the Sixth Amendment requires jury findings beyond a reasonable doubt for any aggravating fact, other than a prior conviction and its elements, used to impose an upper term sentence.
- Denial of a jury trial on aggravating sentencing factors is reviewed under Chapman and requires reversal unless the appellate court finds beyond a reasonable doubt that a jury would have found every relied-upon factor true.
- The harmless-error test under Chapman asks whether any rational fact finder could have reached a contrary conclusion on the aggravating facts, not merely whether evidence supported the trial court's finding.
- A criminal history progressing from non-violent or passive offenses to destructive principal felonies compellingly establishes increasing seriousness as an aggravating factor.
- An appellant forfeits claims of sentencing error regarding relied-upon aggravating factors by failing to raise or argue them in appellate briefing.
Why It Matters
This decision illustrates how California appellate courts apply Wiley's harmless-error standard to salvage upper-term sentences when undisputed criminal records make contrary jury findings irrational.
It highlights that while Wiley enforces constitutional jury trial rights for aggravating facts such as increasing seriousness or probation failure, documented escalation and supervision violations can render the absence of a jury finding harmless.