Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
In 2001 a San Bernardino County jury convicted Robert Baldasaro of murder and attempted murder, with firearm enhancements and prior-felony findings, producing a determinate term plus 100 years to life and life with parole. In August 2024 his counsel filed a commutation application and cover letter asking the court to review the case under Penal Code section 1172.1 and Assembly Bill No. 600.
After briefing and a May 23, 2025 hearing, defense counsel invited the court to hold a resentencing hearing and lower the sentence in the interest of justice. The prosecutor asked the court not to hold a section 1172.1 hearing and noted that declining to exercise discretion would not be appealable.
The trial court explained that some change in law or sentencing scheme might justify recall, but found no such qualifying change here and denied the request to exercise discretion to recall the sentence and hold a resentencing hearing. Baldasaro appealed, arguing the order was appealable and that appointed counsel was ineffective; the Court of Appeal requested supplemental briefing.
The Court’s Holding
The Fourth District, Division Two, held that section 1172.1 does not authorize a defendant to petition for recall and resentencing and does not require the court to respond to such a request. Because the statute permits recall only on the court’s own motion, a defendant’s unauthorized request creates no right to a ruling or to resentencing.
Applying People v. Hodge and related decisions, the court reasoned that declining to initiate recall does not affect a defendant’s substantial rights under Penal Code section 1237, subdivision (b). The court distinguished People v. Olea and People v. Craig, where trial courts conducted merits proceedings resembling authorized resentencing proceedings; here the parties disputed only whether the court should accept the invitation, and the court expressly denied the request to exercise discretion.
The court also rejected the argument that changed sentencing laws supplied jurisdiction, because even a qualifying change leaves recall dependent on the court initiating it on its own motion. It declined to reach the abuse-of-discretion and ineffective-assistance arguments and dismissed the appeal.
Key Takeaways
- A defendant cannot compel a trial court to consider or rule on a request for recall and resentencing under Penal Code section 1172.1.
- An order declining a defendant’s invitation to initiate section 1172.1 resentencing is not appealable because it does not affect substantial rights.
- Procedural steps such as appointing counsel, accepting briefing, and holding a hearing do not automatically convert such a discretionary refusal into an appealable merits decision.
- A change in sentencing law may support discretionary recall but does not eliminate the requirement that the court act on its own motion.
Why It Matters
The opinion joins a line of California appellate decisions limiting appeals from discretionary refusals to initiate section 1172.1 resentencing, while preserving the narrower Olea/Craig situation in which a court actually evaluates a request on the merits.
It also clarifies that Assembly Bill No. 600’s expansion of recall authority does not create a defendant-initiated petition right or appellate jurisdiction.