California Case Summaries

Crooymans v. Givner — Judgment Creditors Cannot Reach Irrevocable Trust Residence Following Temporary Refinancing Transfers

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Crooymans v. Givner
Court
2nd District Court of Appeal
Judge
Viramontes (Gavin Newsom, 2022); Wiley (Jerry Brown, 2018); Scherb (Gavin Newsom, 2025)
Date Decided
2026-11-19
Docket No.
B343072
Status
Unreported / Non-Citable
Topics
qualified personal residence trusts, enforcement of judgments, declaratory relief, alter ego doctrine, probate code

Background

In 2000, Bruce and Kathleen Givner transferred their residential property in Bel Air, California, into two irrevocable Qualified Personal Residence Trusts (QPRTs) administered by an independent trustee. In 2011 and 2012, to refinance the mortgage on the residence, the trustee temporarily deeded the property to the Givners as community property, after which the Givners deeded their interests back into their respective QPRTs, where title remained continuously from June 2013 onward.

In 2020, plaintiffs Kathryn Crooymans and David King obtained a $2.57 million legal malpractice judgment against Bruce Givner and recorded an abstract of judgment against the residence. After an initial civil action was dismissed for lack of subject matter jurisdiction, plaintiffs filed two petitions in the probate department of the Los Angeles County Superior Court seeking a judicial declaration that the QPRTs were revoked by operation of law in January 2011 due to the refinancing transfers, or alternatively that the Givners were alter egos of the trustee and the trusts.

The probate court sustained the defendants' demurrers without leave to amend and entered judgments of dismissal in both actions. Plaintiffs appealed, arguing that they adequately pled an actual controversy for declaratory relief under Code of Civil Procedure section 1060 and viable grounds under the alter ego doctrine.

The Court’s Holding

The Second District Court of Appeal affirmed the dismissals. The court held that plaintiffs failed to plead a cognizable legal basis establishing that the irrevocable QPRTs were revoked by operation of law. Under California law, judgment creditors of a settlor cannot reach the assets of an irrevocable trust under Probate Code sections 18200 and 19001, and a settlor's subsequent conduct after an irrevocable trust is established does not alter the nature of the trust or render it revocable.

The court further held that plaintiffs failed to state a claim under the alter ego doctrine. A trust is not a separate legal entity, and while creditors may theoretically assert alter ego claims against trustees, plaintiffs pled in reverse that the settlors were alter egos of the trustee. Furthermore, plaintiffs failed to plead any facts showing bad faith or that the trusts were established to defraud creditors, as ordinary difficulty in collecting a judgment does not satisfy the inequity requirement of the alter ego doctrine.

Key Takeaways

  • Temporary transfers of real property out of an irrevocable Qualified Personal Residence Trust to refinance a mortgage do not revoke the trust by operation of law under California law.
  • A settlor's subsequent conduct following the creation of an irrevocable trust does not alter its irrevocable status or render trust assets reachable by the settlor's judgment creditors under Probate Code sections 18200 and 19001.
  • Because a trust is not a separate legal entity, the alter ego doctrine does not apply to trusts directly, and alleging that settlors are alter egos of the trustee fails without specific facts showing bad faith or intent to defraud creditors.

Why It Matters

This decision confirms the protection afforded to assets placed in valid irrevocable trusts against subsequent judgment creditors under California law, clarifying that administrative refinancing mechanics do not automatically destroy trust irrevocability.

It also reinforces that mere difficulty in enforcing a money judgment does not satisfy the bad faith requirement necessary to invoke the alter ego doctrine against trust arrangements.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top