Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Zaza Jilaviani, a citizen of Georgia, was encountered by a Border Patrol agent near San Luis, Arizona on November 7, 2022 and served the same day with a Notice to Appear charging him as inadmissible. After his release, he was enrolled in Alternatives to Detention and required to report to the Los Angeles ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations office. On January 17, 2023, he filed an asylum and withholding application that remained pending. On April 27, 2023, Los Angeles ERO terminated him from ATD and enrolled him in the Compliance Assistance Reporting Terminal program.
On July 13, 2026, local authorities arrested Petitioner for misdemeanor shoplifting and released him the same day, apparently on his own recognizance. ICE instructed Petitioner to appear with a Georgian travel document at a reporting appointment on July 29, 2026. Petitioner appeared as directed and was taken into custody after a system search surfaced the arrest. Petitioner alleged he received no notice of the claimed violation and no opportunity to be heard before re-detention. Respondents' one-paragraph opposition did not oppose a bond hearing but argued that the arrest was a changed circumstance and opposed immediate release.
Petitioner sought habeas relief under 28 U.S.C. § 2241, asserting that detention violated 8 U.S.C. § 1226(a) and the Fifth Amendment's Due Process Clause. The court treated the case as a challenge sufficiently independent of the removal merits to fall within § 2241 jurisdiction.
The Court’s Holding
Applying the Mathews v. Eldridge factors, Chief U.S. Magistrate Judge Karen L. Stevenson concluded all three favored Petitioner: he had a strong liberty interest from years of conditional release, the risk of erroneous deprivation was high because ICE re-detained him without any pre-deprivation process, and the government's interest in avoiding a hearing was low given the minimal cost of safeguards. The court concluded Petitioner had a due process right to a hearing before re-detention and that the July 29 custody violated that right.
Because the constitutional violation was the absence of pre-deprivation process, the magistrate judge ordered immediate release under the same conditions that existed before the arrest, required Respondents to file a notice within three days confirming Petitioner's release, and enjoined re-detention without notice and a meaningful opportunity to be heard before a neutral decisionmaker. The court declined to reach the separate § 1226(a) claim as unnecessary and inexpedient, leaving Petitioner free to raise it if detained again.
Key Takeaways
- A noncitizen released on conditions has a protected liberty interest in remaining free, so re-detention generally requires notice and a meaningful pre-deprivation hearing.
- A bare assertion that a new arrest constitutes a changed circumstance does not satisfy due process where the government provides no individualized assessment of flight risk or dangerousness.
- Where re-detention occurs without required pre-deprivation process, immediate release to the prior conditions may be the proper remedy rather than a post hoc bond hearing.
- A court may grant habeas relief on due process grounds and expressly leave a parallel statutory detention claim undecided.
Why It Matters
The decision reinforces a growing line of district-court authority requiring procedural safeguards before ICE re-detains noncitizens previously released to community supervision, even when a recent arrest is offered as justification. As a magistrate judge's order, it carries the authority of the assigned judicial officer and remains subject to any further review within the district court.
The tailored remedy—restoration of prior release conditions, a three-day confirmation notice, and an injunction against future re-detention without a hearing—shows courts using habeas flexibility to address process failures while avoiding unnecessary constitutional rulings.