Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Petitioner Henry Tambriz-Ajpop, a citizen of Guatemala, entered the United States in November 2021 seeking asylum and, because he was then a juvenile, was placed with the Office of Refugee Resettlement. ORR found he was neither a flight risk nor a danger to the community and released him to his father in Florida. He later applied for asylum, obtained a work permit and Social Security number, and had no criminal record.
In July 2026, ICE re-detained him without notice or an opportunity to be heard and without any changed circumstances bearing on flight risk or danger. Petitioner filed an amended 28 U.S.C. § 2241 habeas petition seeking release on his original terms. The Government's Return addressed other issues but argued the Court should decline to reach the due-process question; Petitioner's Traverse renewed the release request and argued waiver.
The Court’s Holding
The Court held that re-detention without notice or a hearing, and without noticeably changed circumstances, violated due process. Citing Morrissey, Young, and Gagnon, it reasoned that individuals released from custody—even conditionally—retain a liberty interest in continued liberty, and it adopted the rule from Saravia v. Sessions that rearrest requires evidence of materially changed circumstances and, if disputed, a prompt hearing before an Immigration Judge.
Because ORR's 2021 release findings remained unrebutted, the Court granted the amended petition and issued a writ ordering release on the same terms and conditions as the December 2021 release. If ICE contends circumstances changed, it must give notice of those changes and an opportunity to be heard promptly before an Immigration Judge. The Clerk was directed to close the case.
Key Takeaways
- A noncitizen released from custody retains a liberty interest in continued liberty, so re-detention generally requires evidence of materially changed circumstances such as danger, flight risk, or a final removal order.
- If the noncitizen disputes the asserted changed circumstances, due process requires a prompt hearing before an Immigration Judge.
- Where the Government's return does not substantively answer a due-process claim and the record shows no changed circumstances, habeas release on the original conditions is an available remedy.
Why It Matters
The order applies Saravia and related authority to a former unaccompanied minor re-detained years after an ORR release, reinforcing that an initial release decision creates reliance interests that cannot be undone without process.
It also illustrates § 2241 as a vehicle for challenging immigration re-detention and ties the remedy directly to restoring the conditions of the prior release rather than ordering unconditional freedom.