Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
In juvenile dependency proceedings concerning her daughter M.R. (born in 2022), S.R. (Mother) had reunification services bypassed under Welfare and Institutions Code section 361.5, subdivisions (b)(10) and (b)(11), based on prior terminations of parental rights over two older children and failure to treat the underlying issues. The juvenile court scheduled a permanency planning hearing under section 366.26, and the Court of Appeal denied Mother's subsequent petition for extraordinary writ relief.
Mother later filed a modification petition under Welfare and Institutions Code section 388 seeking six months of reunification services, citing completion of substance use treatment, ongoing anger management, and a bonding study concluding termination of parental rights would not cause detrimental harm outweighing adoption. The Sonoma County Human Services Department filed a written opposition, and the juvenile court summarily denied the petition without an evidentiary hearing for lack of a prima facie showing.
The Court’s Holding
The First District Court of Appeal, Division Two, affirmed. The court held Mother forfeited her objection to the Department's written opposition by failing to challenge it before the juvenile court. On the merits, the court rejected the claim, confirming child welfare agencies may oppose section 388 petitions at the prima facie stage and juvenile courts may consider such responses when determining whether an evidentiary hearing is warranted.
The appellate court further held the juvenile court acted within its discretion in finding no prima facie showing. While Mother documented service participation, she showed no insight or progress in resolving the chronic anger and behavioral issues that triggered removal. Additionally, because services were bypassed, the proceeding prioritized permanence over reunification, and Mother failed to show that delaying permanency served the child's best interests.
Key Takeaways
- Child welfare agencies may submit written oppositions challenging the prima facie sufficiency of a parent's Welfare and Institutions Code section 388 petition.
- A parent seeking modification under section 388 must show the underlying problems leading to dependency have been ameliorated, not merely that the parent participated in treatment.
- Where reunification services were bypassed under section 361.5, a section 388 petition must establish that delaying permanency and stability promotes the child's best interests.
- Procedural challenges regarding the juvenile court's consideration of agency briefing are forfeited if not timely raised in the trial court.
Why It Matters
The decision clarifies dependency motion practice by affirming that trial courts may consider agency briefing when evaluating a section 388 petition's facial sufficiency. It also underscores that after reunification services are bypassed under section 361.5, establishing a prima facie case requires demonstrable insight and changed circumstances, not routine program enrollment that fails to advance the child's overriding need for permanent placement.