Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Oscar Pavon-Aguiar, proceeding pro se, filed a second habeas corpus petition and a motion for a temporary restraining order on August 26, 2026. After the case was reassigned, he moved on November 9 to expedite proceedings. The district court set a TRO briefing schedule, asked the respondent to address whether this case differed from similar detention cases the court had decided, and temporarily enjoined transfer or removal to preserve the status quo.
The respondent opposed and submitted an immigration judge's July 8, 2026 order granting post-conclusion voluntary departure by September 8, 2026, with alternative removal to Cuba if petitioner failed to leave. Petitioner waived appeal of that order and did not depart by the deadline. The court also noted that petitioner's motion to reopen removal proceedings remained pending before the immigration court.
The Court’s Holding
The court held that petitioner's removal order became final on or around September 9, 2026 when the voluntary-departure deadline passed without departure or appeal, leaving him within the 90-day mandatory detention period under 8 U.S.C. § 1231(a)(2). It therefore could not conclude that his detention was unlawful at that time, and he had not shown a likelihood of success on the merits warranting preliminary relief.
The court denied the TRO motion without prejudice to renewal if detention becomes prolonged, denied the motion to expedite as moot, and referred the habeas petition to the assigned magistrate judge for further proceedings. A footnote explained that the pending motion to reopen did not prevent the removal order from remaining final.
Key Takeaways
- A missed voluntary-departure deadline, combined with a waiver of appeal, can make an alternative removal order final and trigger the 90-day mandatory detention period under 8 U.S.C. § 1231(a)(2).
- A pending motion to reopen before the immigration court does not, by itself, prevent the removal order from remaining final for detention purposes.
- Denial of emergency injunctive relief was without prejudice, preserving the possibility of renewed relief if detention later becomes prolonged.
- The underlying habeas petition remains active and was referred to a magistrate judge; the order resolved only preliminary relief and expedition.
Why It Matters
This order illustrates how federal habeas courts assess immigration detention during the statutory removal-enforcement window, treating an unappealed voluntary-departure alternative order as final once the departure deadline expires.
The without-prejudice denial and referral for further proceedings distinguish an interim emergency ruling from final adjudication of the habeas claim, leaving room for later challenge if detention duration changes the legal analysis.