Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Petitioner John Doe, a former immigration detainee represented by counsel, obtained a writ of habeas corpus under 28 U.S.C. § 2241 after immigration authorities re-detained him without notice or a hearing. He remained in immigration custody for nearly 500 days before the District Judge adopted earlier findings, granted the amended petition, and ordered his immediate release in July 2026; Respondents did not appeal.
Petitioner then timely moved for attorney’s fees under the Equal Access to Justice Act (EAJA), 28 U.S.C. § 2412(d). Respondents asked the court to hold the motion in abeyance pending the Supreme Court’s decision in Montoya Palacios v. Liggins, No. 25-1223, which presents whether the EAJA phrase “any civil action” covers habeas actions challenging civil immigration detention, or alternatively to deny fees on the merits.
The Court’s Holding
The Findings and Recommendations deny the requested abeyance. Binding Ninth Circuit precedent—In re Petition of Hill and Nadarajah v. Holder—already holds that a prevailing party in an immigration habeas proceeding may recover EAJA fees, and a grant of certiorari does not displace circuit law. The Landis stay factors also weighed against waiting because the requested stay would be long and indefinite while Petitioner faced harm from delayed fee recovery.
On the merits, the proceeding is a “civil action” under the EAJA, and Respondents failed to show their position was substantially justified: they offered no defense of re-arresting Petitioner without the process required by 8 C.F.R. § 241.13(i) and no adequate basis for the roughly 16-month detention. The court found the requested rate of $258.46 per hour and 89.9 hours reasonable, yielding $23,235.55.
Key Takeaways
- A grant of certiorari in an out-of-circuit case does not justify staying a fee motion governed by binding circuit precedent.
- Respondents’ failure to defend the agency’s pre-litigation conduct weighed heavily against a finding of substantial justification under the EAJA.
- Fee-litigation time is compensable, and counsel’s exclusion of duplicative and no-charge time supported the reasonableness of the lodestar.
- The recommended award is payable to Petitioner, with direct payment to Pangea Legal Services if Treasury finds no federal debt subject to offset.
Why It Matters
These are Findings and Recommendations from a Magistrate Judge, not a final judgment. The assigned District Judge must act on them after the 14-day objection period, and failure to object may waive appellate review.
The recommendation illustrates that district courts continue applying Hill and Nadarajah while the Supreme Court considers Montoya Palacios, and it treats unlawful re-detention without required process as insufficiently justified to defeat EAJA fees.